Re:Unreal Engine 4.10 is Released
by Impossible on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @03:30PM
(#10549069)
Defold (http://www.defold.com/) is potentially a solid option for 2D. I always find it interesting that some of the biggest requests for primarily 3D engines (Unity, UE4) are better 2D tools, and that no one, outside of Gamemaker, has built a 2D engine that has gained as much adoption or has as strong of a toolset.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think it's because people want the option to move to 3d later if they want. Without having to learn more tools and language. I never liked gamemaker because its game maker language not being useful in other areas. I like making 2d and 3d games and having it be in the same place makes it much easier. I do realize how awesome game maker is and what it does. But it has a few limitations that killed it for me
I'm a 2D developer and have no interest in making 3D games so I prefer an engine focusing exclusively on 2D.
Re:Unreal Engine 4.10 is Released
by andrewmcwatters on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:57PM
(#10550816)
I don't like "engines" like Defold. Because to me that's not an engine. That's a framework. You have few methods exposed like draw/update, some convenience classes and that's about it. It's so comparable to LÖVE (https://love2d.org/) that literally the only difference seems to be a GUI to work with.
Meaning you have to write everything else, yourself.
I wonder if there are other actual 2D engines out there like Grid (http://www.planimeter.org/grid/), or Polycode (http://polycode.org/). Engines that actually take care of networking, predefined game callbacks, resource management, and multiplayer, like the big boys (Unreal, Unity, Source).
Have you used Defold?
Have you built anything with it? I see that it's invite only at the moment. I signed up just to eventually tinker with it, as that's all I really do, but I like to try things out to see how they feel.
Re:Unreal Engine 4.10 is Released
by Impossible on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:15PM
(#10550094)
I haven't so I can't really vouch for it. I suggested it because it seems like an interesting new player in the space and looks powerful.