Re:A mechanism for cognitive influence at a distance?
by gus_massa on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @02:29PM
(#10548657)
I agree that this study is probably 99.9999% wrong, but ...
Were is the mistake? Do someone have access to the original paper and can explain the experimental flaws?
First I thought that 4 pairs of subjects was too low, but with this experiment I'll be surprised to get successful 1 pair that can be tested by independent experts in high controlled situations (i.e. Randi)
They say that they tested with 6 EM patterns. If they used more than 6 (for example 20) it's easy to get a p<0.05 result and filter most of the unsuccessful patterns. https://xkcd.com/882/
Did they repeat the experiment? (I think so.) Did they get the successful result every time for the 4 pairs or after using the average?
Were is the mistake? Do someone have access to the original paper and can explain the experimental flaws?
First I thought that 4 pairs of subjects was too low, but with this experiment I'll be surprised to get successful 1 pair that can be tested by independent experts in high controlled situations (i.e. Randi)
They say that they tested with 6 EM patterns. If they used more than 6 (for example 20) it's easy to get a p<0.05 result and filter most of the unsuccessful patterns. https://xkcd.com/882/
Did they repeat the experiment? (I think so.) Did they get the successful result every time for the 4 pairs or after using the average?
Was it a double blind experiment?
Without the original paper is difficult to know.