News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scrum is the new waterfall by rbanffy on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @08:21PM (#10544144)
Like pointed out before, you need more experience before you can make claims like the ones your teachers make.

They probably need it too.

What you describe is a problem stated in great detail and an API that's needs to be kept backwards compatible. There is nothing in agile that precludes that. Quite the contrary: if you build your tests well enough, everyone who did not participate in the original design can use them as examples of how your system actually works. More than that: you can always prove your system still works as specified, all the time, every time. Agile is good, very good, for dealing with a changing world. And, while the APIs in the system you describe can't change without major investment, if the rest is also difficult to change, whoever did it did it seriously wrong.

You can tell that to your teachers.

Re:Scrum is the new waterfall by kuschku on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @08:28PM (#10544177)
Well, we aren’t in that class to learn how to write software, but how to apply engineering principles to software.

And if you buy a washing machine with lifetime guarantee, you expect it to run forever, but the requirements are mostly static, too.

For a smart TV, on the other hand, you separate the pieces of software with static requirements, and those without. The internal signal decoder, etc will be static. UI might end up rendered by a local web browser, and especially media content will be online.

So if, in 10 years, Netflix defaults, the online content can immediately remove Netflix and replace it with its successor. This UI might make sense with Agile.

But the code the user expects to be reliable and fast – like the code for decoding and displaying a TV signal – will not change, and should be written with waterfall.

    ----------------
In our world, people are constantly complaining about change. People don’t want to buy a new phone every 2 years, they want to buy one phone one time, and be able to use it for 10 years. At least.

People want to be able to buy a fridge or washing machine and use it for decades. Do you buy a new fridge every year?

We are going to be living in a world with internet of things. And with the internet of things we will have shoes and houses running software. More and more software will have to be built with the expectation never to get updated.

Re:Scrum is the new waterfall by parasubvert on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @10:28PM (#10544668)
My Mercedes-Benz has software firmware for my transmission that is updated annually, at the shop.

The software can be updated over the air in a Tesla every few weeks.

Mercedes is working with my company to adopt agile practices and server deployment to disposable cloud environments for their connected car IoT applications.

Industrial and Appliance manufacturers such as Philips, and GE (a 10% investor) are also adopting this same software and methodology for their IoT platforms and applications.

I don't know what else to tell you - there are certainly areas where you correctly point out you need to get it right the first time. But you keep making projections about the future of immutable software that are contradictory to all the evidence.

The world is a big place and even in Deutschland the big industrial manufacturers are adopting lean and agile. Cars at Toyota and Honda (and many others) are developed with Lean Product development principles - not a big up front design plan, but test-first, concurrent, iterative, incremental engineering.

One can buy hardware that lasts a decade - the software can and will evolve except in constrained environments. A washing machine is not a constrained environment.

Re:Scrum is the new waterfall by kuschku on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @10:32PM (#10544679)
No one is going to update their washing machine. No one.

Out of the people I know, most never updated their phone software or the firmware of their consoles. My mum was, until a week ago, running on her PC Windows Vista with the last update being downloaded in 2006, when we moved into this house and I had run Windows Update for her.

A washing machine is probably the most constrained environment in any home. No one’s going to update it. When you turn it on, you want it to just work. Same with the smart fridge.

These devices have a lifetime of decades, and no one’s going to update them.

Same with cars, most people don’t want them to be updated.

Remember, this is Deutschland, we still use Fax for business communication.