This is really the heart of it, I've really only worked in environments that have been top down as their implementation of scrum. When the engineer team got to decide, we picked Kanban. The lightest process for us.
Scrum top down. I buy that. Bottom up? I'd give it a try, but the team needs the ability to say "no".
I do believe scrum can be an effective tool for a few use cases, but people often underestimate the warning signs. "Scrum is easy to learn, but difficult to master." - https://www.scrumalliance.org/community/articles/2011/may/sc...