Re:What Open-Access Publishing Actually Costs
by dougmccune on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @12:38PM
(#10540828)
I was arguing the cost of APC can only be low in the megajournal review format precisely because of the points you mentioned. So I think we agree, the type of peer review drives the acceptance rate, so with a higher acceptance rate you can charge a lower per-article APC.
Consider that PLOS ONE, because it doesn't review for importance, has a much higher acceptance rate. Only accepted papers pay processing charges, so each accepted article has to subsidize the review and rejection of all the rejected papers. In PLOS Biology or PLOS Medicine, with a low acceptance rate, each accepted article has to subsidize review of numerous other articles, driving the cost per published article way up.