Re:The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
by jqm on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @02:33PM
(#10541769)
Many of the rules for the house and senate are specified, very clearly, as well.
Sorry, it isn't a "vague document" nor a "rough guideline". It is very specific on many points. Also, the idea that no one but trained professionals can read or understand if the document is being followed is not only wrong but abhorrent. Certainly, legally the judiciary is to interpret the law for implementation, I don't disagree. But again... we as voters have a right and responsibility to read the rules, to understand the rules, to ascertain if they are being followed and to vote accordingly. The ultimate power, in theory, resides with us, not with "trained professionals". This principal is of extreme importance for our system and seems to be quite often forgotten.
Re:The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
by gnaritas on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @02:49AM
(#10545320)
I agree that we as voters vote our interests; I don't, and won't agree that the average joe can read and correctly interpret the constitution and they never will. It is a legal document and understanding it requires more than just the words on the page.
Re:The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
by jqm on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:44AM
(#10547180)
That's a common line from some sectors. It gets repeated a lot. There is probably a reason for that but I don't believe it's objective.
Re:The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
by gnaritas on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @12:47PM
(#10547927)
It's common because it's true, whether you choose it accept it or not really doesn't matter, legal documents cannot be understood merely by the words on the page. They exist in a field of precedence and lacking an understanding of the precedence the common person cannot properly understand the intended meaning which whether you see it or not is referencing that precedence.
Re:The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
by jqm on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @07:41PM
(#10550508)
I'm sorry. You don't need legal training to read and understand most of the Constitution. Much of it is fairly plain and straightforward. Much of the "context" you speak of often comes after the fact. I would suggest rather than trying to beat a worn out point you take half an hour and actually read the document. You can do it... even without a law degree. We can read it.. we can see if it is manifestly being violated, we can vote accordingly. That is the intent. The intent is not that we are governed by an army of lawyers twisting a document into whatever they choose.
Re:The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
by gnaritas on Thursday November 12, 2015 @01:38AM
(#10551656)
Don't play superior, you're not; I've read it more than a few times and worked in law enforcement. You think your interpretation is somehow right while ignoring the reality that reasonable people disagree on the meaning of it and denying they even can. You're blinded by your own ideology. We're done.
Re:The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
by jqm on Thursday November 12, 2015 @07:27PM
(#10557205)
I'm sorry you think I'm playing superior. That's not my intent. I'm also sorry you feel as you do. I think I've made my point. You seem to be deliberately ignoring it. You appear to have heard something and are parroting it without thinking about it. I don't think that's the best thing to do. And I agree, we are done.
Just because you can find a few things that seems specific is in no way an argument against my point; I didn't say it had no specifics, I said much of it is vague and intentionally so. The real law of the land is the U.S. Code which is the actual law derived from the framework the constitution lays out. The notion that anyone can understand the constitution is simply wrong; without a correct legal grounding in common law and precedence you have no idea what the constitution actually means or how law is derived from it. Just because you can read a sentence does not mean you understand it the same way everyone else does nor that everyone agrees on what the words mean. That's why we have judges and precedence and a common law foundation, to guide the interpretation in a direction most can agree on.