Re:A decade into a project to digitize U.S. immigration form...
by lazaroclapp on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @06:50PM
(#10543603)
There isn't really a monopoly on governance, though. On the short term there is political alternance, on the long term there is the rise and fall of states.
Of course, the first one would matter a lot more if: a) people voted based on previous performance, not vague future promises; b) there were more than two options in competition.
As for the second. The second works quite well, but not a time scale that yet cares about well-designed websites... fail to figure out say steel alloys and gunpowder, though, and you'll see this competition in action... ;)
> The root problem is not bureaucracy either. Companies like Amazon, Google, and Microsoft have fairly large bureaucracies yet they routinely successfully complete massive software projects.
>...The root problem, I think, is that the people who are put in charge of these massive software projects -- typically, MBAs or lawyers by training -- often don't know anything about how to develop software at scale.
I don't think these explanations are mutually exclusive. If you're right about the root problem being the technical expertise of leaders, then one can still argue that the Amazons of the world slowly rise to the top and displace the K-marts, but an incompetent government can persist indefinitely because it has a monopoly on governance.