Making no comment on the effect of such operations on housing costs or other such matters, AirBnB, like Uber, has succeeded by making a uniquely good user experience, even as they flout regulations and the law in general.
A conversation-starter I like to use on my hosts is to ask about their bad experiences with tenants, and most of them tend to have fairly boring ones, usually about some hard-to-please guest or another. I've yet to hear of one of the drug-fuelled late-night orgies that discussions on AirBnB seem to hold as commonplace, even from hosts who have been renting dozens of apartments for years.
Then again, I do tend to stay at apartments that are available monthly, which may make a difference.
Not sure if they'd want to get into that, but it would be a huge new market. It's also a market that might benefit from some "intermediation", in the interests of information symmetry and fairness.
But goodness me, the rental market does need an overhaul!
I think the big losers here, outside of hotels, are renters. As someone who is trying to rent/buy in popular areas of the country (Cambridge, UK), I can see how houses will no longer come up for rent - which sucks, as the article points out.
I guess there could (hopefully) be a point where there are so many professionally rented homes that it no longer represents such an attractive proposition and the first movers enjoying these fat years of high revenues eventually lose out.
Either that, or Airbnb will become the new way to rent, who knows...