News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The end of Haiti? by ars on Thursday January 14, 2010 @07:22PM (#1053927)
Historically disasters (and wars) have the opposite effect.

In the short term it's terrible, but long term a disaster usually spurs rebuilding and economic activity that results in a better situation than what was there before.

Re:The end of Haiti? by yread on Friday January 15, 2010 @08:52AM (#1054851)
The 1755 Lisbon earthquake suggests otherwise. If the disaster is big enough it can wipe out a country.
Re:The end of Haiti? by JimmyL on Thursday January 14, 2010 @11:48PM (#1054290)
The problem with using that model is that it assumes that once the war/disaster ends, there is a reasonable amount of time (10-15 years) in which the rebuilding can take hold and the economy can develop.

Haiti gets a significant natural disaster every three to four years - generally hurricanes and floods, but in this case, an earthquake. So every time they start to rebuild, they get hit again and it all gets undone.

Re:The end of Haiti? by simplicissimus on Friday January 15, 2010 @04:40AM (#1054570)
Somalia is a rather compelling, and modern, example of a sovereign nation damaged beyond recovery by war. Rebuilding might occur on such a scale if the country had recently sustained such economic capacity sometime in the past. Haiti sadly has not, and its gov't even before the earthquake would not have been capable of stewarding any such renaissance.
Re:The end of Haiti? by ugh on Friday January 15, 2010 @08:24AM (#1054808)
In Europe, maybe. Where there was - even after the devastation of the second world war - still enough infrastructure left to rebuild. Where both the Soviet Union and the US wanted to win over allies becasue Europe hat just become a cold war front.
Re:The end of Haiti? by borism on Thursday January 14, 2010 @08:38PM (#1054026)
Pretty ridiculous statement in my opinion.

Life goes on, disaster or not.

There's supposedly always better situation in the future, it is pretty dubious to claim that wars and cataclysms accelerate long term development.

Re:The end of Haiti? by jacoblyles on Friday January 15, 2010 @01:03AM (#1054369)
It's Mancur Olson's "Institutional Sclerosis" growth theory. He claimed to have shown that growth rates increase after a large shock to the existing order. His explanation for this is that institutions tend to be corrupted by special interests over time, feeding on the wealth of society. Shocks give people a chance to start afresh.
Re:The end of Haiti? by borism on Friday January 15, 2010 @08:02AM (#1054785)
Doesn't that mean that winning side of military conflict gets even more corrupt afterwards?
Re:The end of Haiti? by jacoblyles on Saturday January 16, 2010 @06:05PM (#1057661)
He does claim to show that the losing side in several conflicts experienced higher growth rates after wars than would be expected from historical data (the American south after the civil war, Japan after WWII, etc.). Critics point to counter-examples, but as far as I know it's considered a reasonable (though not air-tight) theory.
Re:The end of Haiti? by seldo on Thursday January 14, 2010 @11:45PM (#1054286)
It depends where you're talking about. In an area reasonably prepared for disasters, they actually do bring about increased prosperity -- Florida has periodic construction booms after hurricanes, and a majority are insured, so financial losses are constrained to the big insurance companies.

On the other hand, even in a developed nation, a major disaster can end the life of an area -- New Orleans is perhaps two-thirds of its former size and looks unlikely to grow.

In this case of Haiti, a steady and dedicated stream of aid could help rebuild the country, but history has shown that the international community's attention to the desperate plight of that nation has always been short-lived.

Sadly, I fear it will be worse than before, and remain so.

Re:The end of Haiti? by timwiseman on Thursday January 14, 2010 @08:41PM (#1054037)
There's supposedly always better situation in the future, it is pretty dubious to claim that wars and cataclysms accelerate long term development.

It depends on what you mean. Wars have historically accelerated technology development, at least in the short term.

If you mean development more generally, then no probably not. The civilian technology would eventually get developped, if more slowly without the major push of a war. In the process, people and resources are destroyed.

Re:The end of Haiti? by chrischen on Thursday January 14, 2010 @08:58PM (#1054057)
Perhaps it's like accelerating your car. You gain more speed faster at the expense of efficiency.
Re:The end of Haiti? by timwiseman on Friday January 15, 2010 @08:33AM (#1054827)
I think that's a pretty good analogy.
Re:The end of Haiti? by borism on Thursday January 14, 2010 @08:56PM (#1054053)
Of course I mean human development.

Tech development is self accelerating (with main constraint being human developers, who's numbers wars and catastrophes reduce, btw).

Conflicts provide some bump, but I would say it's pretty insignificant in the large scheme of things.

Re:The end of Haiti? by ars on Thursday January 14, 2010 @09:29PM (#1054094)
I didn't say development. I said economic activity.