Re:The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
by acdha on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @07:50AM
(#10538976)
You're correct that it's ultimate up to judges to interpret the law but in this case it's really hard to see the full range of NSA activities surviving a 4th amendment challenge. The recent ruling shows how that's likely to go unless they're allowed to play the national security excuse:
There's a simple rule I use for this: are they trying to prevent a court from discussing the mechanism?
You never see e.g. the FBI trying to argue that it'll endanger national security to acknowledge that they have the technical capacity to wiretap phones because that's clearly legal as long as they have a warrant. They might try to keep specific instances sealed (e.g. mob cases where retaliation is likely) but the capability and process is not secret.
As with the NSA, however, that changes once they exceed their legal authority and you see that when they do things like drop charges against known criminals rather than discuss how they used a Stingray to intercept cell-phone traffic. There's no reason to do that unless you know that the system isn't designed to follow the legal rules and thus would never survive a real court.
https://ecf.dcd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/show_public_doc?2013cv0...
There's a simple rule I use for this: are they trying to prevent a court from discussing the mechanism?
You never see e.g. the FBI trying to argue that it'll endanger national security to acknowledge that they have the technical capacity to wiretap phones because that's clearly legal as long as they have a warrant. They might try to keep specific instances sealed (e.g. mob cases where retaliation is likely) but the capability and process is not secret.
As with the NSA, however, that changes once they exceed their legal authority and you see that when they do things like drop charges against known criminals rather than discuss how they used a Stingray to intercept cell-phone traffic. There's no reason to do that unless you know that the system isn't designed to follow the legal rules and thus would never survive a real court.