Except that when I procured an external modem it reproduced the exact same issue.
A lot of time was wasted trying to figure out what happened. Several fruitless rounds of OS reinstalls later I started to swap test any removable component out of desperation (there really wasn't many on a laptop) and voila the problem went away once a particular stick of RAM had been removed. Later tests found that it will pass most tests in MemTest86+ except this a copy operation over repeated runs.
I have no idea why the symptoms were so peculiar, perhaps when using dial-up connections the OS had been repeatedly loading the network stack in the memory address close to the affected blocks and after a while it will inevitably encounter a IO error and crash. This is just one personal anecdote, but with a complex system it is certainly possible for RAM issues to appear like other kinds of failure.
Chance of ram issues causing other hardware failure... ZERO