Re:Our broken peer review system, in one saga
by rubidium on Monday November 09, 2015 @10:34PM
(#10537463)
Yea, it seemed like a pretty typical fight to publish an interesting but thin finding. Not that the publishing system isn't broken, but this story doesn't seem to highlight why very well.
Re:Our broken peer review system, in one saga
by stdbrouw on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @05:51AM
(#10538624)
Not all science is theory-based. If biologists discover a new species, I sure hope they're not required to have a theory about why the species "has to exist"; even detailed descriptions and study of its habitat and organs can come later.
To go back to basics: start with a theory or model, make a prediction based on that model, then test to see if that prediction is correct. In this work, the authors explicitly stay away from anything other than a hand-waving explanation of their results, and seem surprised that the reviewers keep asking them to "frame" their results in a broader context.
It would be as if Newton published an observation of fruit falling off a tree, and failed to mention gravity. An interesting observation, perhaps, but not an advancement of science.