Re:Our broken peer review system, in one saga
by danieltillett on Monday November 09, 2015 @09:44PM
(#10537297)
The problem is the use of which journal a paper is published in as a measure of the quality of the paper. Until moronic hiring and tenure committees use a better measure of research quality than the journal a paper is published in then these sub-optimal practices will continue.
It’s hard for reviewers to politely articulate “we just didn’t think your paper was cool enough for our journal” or “we thought your analysis was weak”, but most of them did seem to be trying. My impression is that the author didn’t really take the criticism to heart, and had trouble reading between the lines.
These journals surely get many similar paper submissions, and this authors’ opinion notwithstanding, they can’t publish them all.
I agree that the system is too slow, too arbitrary, and too high-stakes though. It’s tragic that quantity and venue of published papers is the main way academics are judged.
It would indeed be nice if scholars could (as an option) publish their papers without as much oversight, and then have more of the discussion back and forth about the paper’s relevance take place in public. Then if the paper turns out to be significant, it could be republished in a leading journal.