Re:Our broken peer review system, in one saga
by dougmccune on Monday November 09, 2015 @08:32PM
(#10537063)
There are actually a lot of solutions to the problem, and the author seems aware of them, as discussed at the very end of the article. There are pre-print servers like arXiv, there are mega journals that have a slightly different type of peer review (what I'd call methodological review as opposed to"importance" review) like PLOS One, PeerJ, SAGE Open, etc. And yet even though the author is aware of these options, he acknowledges that it all comes down to how his publication will be perceived by his peers, and the non-traditional options simply don't yet have enough reputational weight. So fundamentally even though there are lots of other options, they aren't realistic because of the politics of academia.
To be fair, most of these non-traditional systems cater almost exclusively to hard sciences and don't focus on sociology.
If you put a paper there, and someone reads it/finds it useful, or if someone does a literature search on the subject, the arXiv entry will get cited.
<looks at arXiv, notes lack of a sociology section>
I don't know why arXiv hasn't broadened its scope outside of the natural sciences, but I'm certain that a) Ginsparg has a good reason, and b) they're happy to help others implement similar systems.