Re:Mathematicians prove the triviality of English
by pnt12 on Monday November 09, 2015 @10:15PM
(#10537403)
>A lot of people here seem to be taking it a great deal more seriously than any of the relevant authors.
Lack of context, probably. I fetched the text from my RSS reader - I didnt know where it came from. From the title, I had a false expectation, as other HN readers seemed to have.
They can't really be "incorrect", because they made up the rules. It would be more accurate to observe something like this definition of trivial is itself rather trivial and useless.
It's a fun word game, and nothing more. As this appears to be a recreational math column in the Guardian, there's nothing wrong with that. It's no Martin Gardner, but it's not being put forth as some sort of major result or anything either.
A lot of people here seem to be taking it a great deal more seriously than any of the relevant authors.