News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How do I evaluate my equity offer? by geofft on Sunday November 08, 2015 @07:06PM (#10530661)
> Simple thought experiment: would you prefer "$100" or "51% chance at $0, 49% chance at $1000"? I strongly suspect you'd prefer the latter, even though the median for that scenario is $0.

$100 or $490 or $1000 isn't really enough to make a meaningful difference in my life decisions, so I'll take the higher-expected-value option, simply because the money is strictly bonus. If I want to plan with the money, though, I want the lower-risk option.

In particular, compare a $90K + equity salary with a $120K + no equity one, where there's a small chance that the equity is worth well over $100K in three years. With the higher salary, if I want to spend it now, I can get an apartment closer to work, I can visit my family more or take more vacation, etc. Alternatively, if I save it, I can take a year off of work and fund my own work, I can put a down payment on a house, etc.

It's certainly true that if I win the equity game, I can take well over a year off of work, I can put a larger down payment on a better house, etc. But if I don't, I have to keep working and living in an apartment. And since I have no guarantee of it, I certainly can't spend that expected value now. From the purpose of planning, if I actively want to do one of these things in three years, I'd rather have a guarantee of being able to do it somehow, than a chance of being able to do it very well and a chance of nothing.

Once I have a guarantee of being able to buy a house in three years, I can do things like plan to start a family then. If I have such a goal in mind, it's clearly better to choose the lower-risk thing, if it provides enough money to enable this sort of long-term planning.

$100 vs. $490 will hardly make any difference to how many people I can invite to the wedding.

Re:Ask HN: How do I evaluate my equity offer? by lpolovets on Sunday November 08, 2015 @07:53PM (#10530830)
I hadn't looked at this from that perspective. That's a great point! =)

The only thing I'd add is that 5-10 years ago, a startup salary was a big cut from a BigCo salary. Like maybe 30-50% lower. These days, the difference between a startup salary and a Google salary might be something like $125k vs $150k -- and $125k is already enough money for taking vacations or having a down payment after 5-10 years of saving. Perhaps if there's a downturn, startup salaries will become low again, but that's not the case right now.

Re:Ask HN: How do I evaluate my equity offer? by seattle_spring on Sunday November 08, 2015 @11:44PM (#10531442)
That's not quite the whole story though. Sure, base salary might be $125k vs $150k, but in reality it'd be:

- Startup: $125k base salary, small potential for an OK payout but a large potential that you'll take away that salary and nothing more after 4 years.

- BigCo: $150k salary, $200k RSU over 4 years, 15% bonus every year

Not counting the inevitable refreshers, bonus multipliers, raises, etc, you're really looking at $500k / 4 yr at a startup vs $890k from bigco. That's not an insignificant difference, and I feel like I'm being pretty conservative with the BigCo numbers.