News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by mbrock on Sunday November 08, 2015 @12:54PM (#10529179)
One fascinating part of this story is Göran Lambertz, who was chancellor of justice during the trials and is now a supreme court judge.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6ran_Lambertz

He fervently maintains that Quick is indeed guilty, and that there was nothing at all wrong with the proceedings of the justice system. In fact he claims, to this day as far as I know, that the evidence against Quick is "extraordinarily convincing."

While a supreme court judge, this spring he released a 502-page book "Quickologi" which he presents as a thorough debunking of the notions of Quick's innocence and any suggestion of a scandal.

That's all a bunch of politics, but around here what should be more interesting is Lambertz's interpretation of probability.

In chapter 15 of his book, he performs a calculation of the evidence that Quick is guilty—and arrives at a probability of 183%. He concludes this from a chain of reasoning that involves adding contingent probabilities in a wildly spurious way.

After a professor of mathematics described exactly how ludicrous this is in a blog post...

http://haggstrom.blogspot.se/2015/05/quickologisk-sannolikhe...

...Lambertz replied on his own blog saying that he was eagerly awaiting such a rebuttal, since his aim was to "provoke a discussion."

In other words, the chancellor of justice responsible at the time of this case, this current supreme court judge, is a blog troll who uses fraudulent statistics to intentionally misrepresent the relevant evidence.

So, yeah. I hope I don't ever have to go to court. It's like a mashup of Franz Kafka, Lewis Carroll, and Stephen Colbert.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by StavrosK on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:27PM (#10529495)
> arrives at a probability of 183%.

I don't see anything wrong with the math. It simply means that Quick is certainly guilty, with an 83% chance of being double-guilty, which is an obscure legal term I don't expect the technocrat audience of HN to be familiar with.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by jacquesm on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:39PM (#10529545)
If you use the word 'probability' the expected range of values is 0-1 or 0 through 100%, you can't really be 'double-guilty' of anything. See also: Bayes theorem, which was formulated expressly with the idea of evaluating evidence. If I see the words 'probability' and '183%' in one sentence than as part of that audience I suspect a buggy algorithm, not a new interpretation of the word probability.

If you can be double guilty of something then does that mean you get to serve two sentences for the same crime too?

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by StavrosK on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:52PM (#10529594)
Aw, I didn't think I'd need the detestable "/s", Jacques :(
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by jacquesm on Sunday November 08, 2015 @03:22PM (#10529717)
Hehe, ok then. You had me wondering there.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by _0ffh on Sunday November 08, 2015 @04:38PM (#10530068)
And Poe's law strikes again...
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by lomnakkus on Sunday November 08, 2015 @03:14PM (#10529680)
I think you missed parent poster's sarcasm :).
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by jacquesm on Sunday November 08, 2015 @03:22PM (#10529719)
Absolutely.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by Turbo_hedgehog on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:51PM (#10529592)
Think you missed the tongue-in-cheekiness of the post you replied to.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by fasdf3asdf on Sunday November 08, 2015 @03:17PM (#10529697)
Reminds me of high school statistics class, when the teacher read out in class after a quiz, "[Name] answered negative 4% for the probability in question 3. This is in fact the probability that [Name] passed the quiz."
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by chris_wot on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:35PM (#10530539)
Sort of like a reverse double jeopardy, huh?
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by da1 on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:11PM (#10530437)
> So, yeah. I hope I don't ever have to go to court. It's like a mashup of Franz Kafka, Lewis Carroll, and Stephen Colbert.

I highly recommend going to a courtroom and just observe a trial.

The level of dishonesty, stupidity and incompetence is tremendous.

At the jurisdiction where I did that trials have all audio recorded. I saw the judge asking to stop the recording, basically saying out loud that the defendant was guilty because he felt it (basically he was creepy), resume the recording and then make some bullshit excuse to validate what he already had decided on a hunch.

I never had much respect for people involved with the law. I lost whatever little respect I had left that day.

I was actually recording audio (probably illegal and criminal) so at home I confirmed it just in case I was under some kind of delusion.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by vijayr on Sunday November 08, 2015 @10:34PM (#10531236)
It is amazing that so many societies in the world are able to function well, considering the pathetic nature of their legal systems.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by MistahKoala on Sunday November 08, 2015 @08:20PM (#10530908)
Why didn't you anonymously leak it?
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by da1 on Sunday November 08, 2015 @09:16PM (#10531041)
Because I was identified before getting in and I was the only person not involved in the trial there.

I would be in serious trouble.

That laptop's disk went kaput so eventually I lost it (this might have been 6 years ago).

I did come back but never heard anything that outrageous.

When the judge says "stop recording" my heart sank because I realized that recordings were not an accurate description of what happened there.

Recently I read about a case where a judge convicted a witness, just like that.

Eventually it was overturned but now that judge is at the European Court of Human Rights.

Convicting the witness without an extra trial is far more serious and nothing came out of it...

Edit: Court name was wrong.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by chris_wot on Sunday November 08, 2015 @11:34PM (#10531410)
That can only mean it was Helena Jäderblom. There is only one judge from each country :-) but that's dreadful!
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by PeterWhittaker on Sunday November 08, 2015 @01:31PM (#10529306)
I hope I don't ever have to go to court. It's like a mashup of Franz Kafka, Lewis Carroll, and Stephen Colbert.

Upvoted for that one line alone. Brilliant.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by chris_wot on Sunday November 08, 2015 @01:47PM (#10529354)
Isn't Sweden the country that was trying to extradite Julian Assange? If their Supreme Court judges can come up with probabilities greater than 100%, then I seriously fear for their justice system!
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by krig on Sunday November 08, 2015 @03:52PM (#10529851)
I'm not going to comment on the Assange case itself since I don't know the details, I'm not a lawyer, and there's so much misinformation out there that it must be almost impossible even for the prosecutors to keep track of what "the case" actually is, but... indeed, the swedish justice system is in many ways archaic. I guess unjust is the best word to describe it. Basically, it's a system that has evolved over time in a country with such low crime rates that simply being charged for a crime in itself is enough to make you guilty in the eyes of the court. If I'm not mistaken, I think Japan has a similar situation, and Japanese and Swedish culture seem strangely similar in other ways too. At least to this swede.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by mbrock on Sunday November 08, 2015 @04:02PM (#10529897)
Swedish drug policy is also seriously unjust, according to the UN's Deputy High Commissioner for Human Rights.

http://www.thelocal.se/20151108/un-swedish-drug-policy-viola...

> Sweden has one of the EU's most restrictive drug policies, with zero tolerance for drug use and possession. At the same time, the rate of drug-induced deaths is among the highest in the union, and they are on the rise.

> [...] Only six out of Sweden's 290 municipalities offer needle exchange [...]

> "We always look at Sweden as a very advanced country with the most progressive policies, and I was surprised to see that it lags behind a number of other countries in terms of its policies on drugs," deputy high commissioner for human rights Flavia Pansieri told SVT.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by da1 on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:34PM (#10530534)
> We always look at Sweden as a very advanced country with the most progressive policies

Sweden and Norway were the undisputed leaders in lobotomies per capita up to the 1970s so not long ago.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by Excavator on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:47PM (#10530583)
Perhaps that's why so many people appear to be addicted to aspirin, one every morning.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by Excavator on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:44PM (#10530568)
Seems to be needed given how people handle prescription drugs.

Way too many people ignore doctors orders and stop taking their prescription drugs once they "feel well" and then they keep it around in case they or someone they know "feels ill".

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by chris_wot on Sunday November 08, 2015 @11:28PM (#10531394)
I don't think that's specific to Sweden, sadly.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by da1 on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:03PM (#10530398)
Sweeden has many "peculiarities", the one that tremendously impresses me is that voting is effectively not secret.

From what was described to me, when you vote you ask for a sheet of paper. You can ask for several but you'll get weird looks from people. The end result is that anyone that votes in fringe options is effectively identified because no one else asks for those options.

The person that told me this was competely oblivious to any problem with it. When I mentioned that this makes voting "de facto" not secret he mentioned that next time he would ask for all options.

I just don't get it.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by lobster_johnson on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:20PM (#10530478)
For those curious, the process is described here [1]. As a voter, you go to a table and pick a ballot that represents your choice. You can pick a pre-printed ballot with your party's name on it, or you can take a blank ballot and write it manually. If you want to keep your choice secret, you can pick a bunch of random ballots, but submit just one of them.

For comparison, in Sweden's neighbouring country of Norway, the voting booth where you pick and fill out the ballot is covered with a curtain. You fill out the ballot (they're all printed on the same type of paper), which you fill out and fold so that it hides the contents. You then go over to an election worker, who confirms your identity and gives you an envelope to put the ballot in, which you then seal and put in the drop box.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_Sweden#Voting

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by da1 on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:31PM (#10530519)
Thank you very much for the detailed description.

> or you can take a blank ballot and write it manually

I've been told that in small places in the countryside doing this is tremendously deviant and carries serious covert social consequences.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by chris_wot on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:37PM (#10530543)
That seems very backward. They took the blind ballot and modified it, missing the point entirely!
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by Excavator on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:32PM (#10530523)
It varies, usually you have all the papers laid out in a room. You're then free to pick just the ones you'll vote on or you can do like some and take one of each.

Parties will often also send voting blankets in the mail so you can somewhat secretly bring your own papers from home. The only issue there is that some places sets up the voting stands in such a poor way that people almost can see what you're doing anyway.

Another issue that has occurred during the past couple of elections is that the RF/AFA frat boys decided to stand guard at the entrance of some voting places, trying to stop people who intended to vote for SD.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by da1 on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:58PM (#10530633)
How come this is never brought up in international settings, say the UN or EU?

It's so outlandish when I first heard it I though people were just joking.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by purplelobster on Sunday November 08, 2015 @03:46PM (#10529822)
Hey, at least they're trying to use math! ;) It does make me fear for our justice system, but people are people, and I've realized they're no different anywhere really. The right education can limit our faults but only to a degree.

I also believe that the government very likely has been influenced by American lobbying in the Assange case. The U.S. Is Sweden's largest export outside the EU, and obviously a large importer as well, therefore highly susceptible to pressure.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by chris_wot on Sunday November 08, 2015 @11:31PM (#10531405)
If they are using Mathematics to make court judgements (which granted, he's not...but he's still a judicial officer making comments about an going case) then it would behoove him to know that probability can only ever be measured between 0 and 1. That's the most OBVIOUS thing about probability I can imagine!
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by johansch on Sunday November 08, 2015 @04:21PM (#10529982)
If you have to ask that question you're probably in the 96% (my estimate) that are grossly misinformed about this case, due to international media being idiotic and easily manipulated by Assange's pawns.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by chris_wot on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:20PM (#10530477)
Why don't you, you know, inform me?
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by scintill76 on Sunday November 08, 2015 @08:00PM (#10530850)
Here's some background on the allegations: http://www.theguardian.com/media/2010/dec/17/julian-assange-... The final three paragraphs are a pretty good summary of the holes in the story.

Timeline: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-11949341 Note that between March and August of this year, Swedish prosecutors couldn't be bothered to come to London to question him, allowing most of the charges against him to expire. This in spite of them finally compromising on that, precisely beause the cases would soon expire.

I won't pretend it's a clear-cut case in either direction, but the supicion that he's being unjustly targeted certainly has merit. The victims go to the police, days later, to try to foce him to take an STD test(?) -- the police can't do that, but here have a rape case as a consolation (which of course instantly leaks to the press. And the discussion between the two women about selling their story to the press was just a joke, naturally.) Then the Swedish prosecutors close and re-open the case, the UK spends millions guarding the man, Sweden won't come and question him in the UK (which could be a valid position on sovereignty, but they had finally said they would come to the UK!), and the UK stops guarding him. Yeah, there's definitely nothing fishy here! All the resources spent here have nothing to do with the man in question being an enemy to the United States and their allies. /s

Some of this may be a case of international bureaucratic bumbling being indistuingishable from malicious conspiracy.

I'm open to hearing the other side if I'm missing things. Assange doesn't sound like a very pleasant person, he was probably at the least stupid to get himself ensnared in this, is now by definition an outlaw, and this narrative would be a convenient way to re-cast himself as the victim if he's not. But that's orthogonal to whether he is a rapist.

Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by jacobush on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @06:54PM (#10543629)
Personally I think Assange is a rapist under Swedish law AND that the Swedish state cowed in to US weight, big time, as per parent.
Re:Thomas Quick: The serial killer who wasn't by chris_wot on Sunday November 08, 2015 @11:23PM (#10531378)
That's pretty informative and clocks with what I know. So much for me being misinformed!