Re:When Gold Isn’t Worth the Price
by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2015 @06:46PM
(#10526721)
Who chooses the editorialized title? It can't be the submitter; submitters aren't supposed to have a privileged position.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I'd have thought the submitter would put one if they felt it was needed or a mod could put one if the submitter hadn't. If the submitter puts a bad title then I guess it might still need editing ... so still space for those that want to argue about it! Win-win!!
It's a principle of HN that submitters don't get extra privileges w/r/t stories. Once they're posted, they're community property. So the feature you propose can't be as simple as a second text input for the editorialized title: that gives the submitter a kind of "super-comment" that other community members don't get.
But submissions themselves are a sort of super-comment, and you get to put a meta comment if you want to ...
The only solution that I can see that avoids "priveleges" is to actually give mod priveleges that allow a cadre of users to give a [sub-]title iff they respect neutrality of the title.
Going this far seems a bit OTT though whilst there do seem to be less than perfect options that are better than the current position.