Re:The Case Against the Universal Basic Income
by jjoonathan on Friday November 06, 2015 @11:44PM
(#10523754)
Not only that, but its primary objection is buried towards the end, receives a tiny fraction of the essay's length, and so thoroughly lacks originality that it has literally driven people in the opposite direction (I originally went searching for other schools of economic thought because I didn't believe the "jobs will appear" mantra, not the other way around).
It feels like a student essay where the author has a word quota but no actual point so instead they just aimlessly wander along tangents until they pass the "finish line."
Re:The Case Against the Universal Basic Income
by Absentinsomniac on Saturday November 07, 2015 @01:58AM
(#10524012)
Most of this thing reads more like an argument for than against.
In making this case, the author raises a bunch of bogeyman images of everything else being sacrificed on the altar of UBI. This is a paranoia tactic. The real exchanges made are done at the level of individual politicians horse-trading against rivals and various interest groups. It's possible for something to be popular enough that capital is told to go get dunked, despite all its other advantages, because the alternative is political suicide. It doesn't happen often, but this is one of those issues that captures people's imagination in a big way.