Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense
by lfam on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:31PM
(#10523203)
> it just sounds like a waterfall with a few bandpass filters changing between the verse and chorus.
That's a good way to put it. I hate over-compressed music. It sounds terrible and is no fun to listen to once you notice the issue.
But, are you an audio engineer? I ask because I work in the field, and all engineers I know accept that dynamic range compression is a necessary part of creating recorded music. The problem is when you abuse compression to create a wall of noise with no dynamic range.
It's like autotune: you can use it to correct one bad note, or you can abuse it create T-Pain.
The engineers behind The Pixies and Nirvana [1], and all dubstep producers use or have used compression at various stages of the creative process.
[1]
I guarantee you that whoever mixed Smells Like Teen Spirit spent a lot of time doing the compression on that song.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense
by cdcarter on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:40PM
(#10523231)
Obviously there is a difference between "excessive compression" (the term the GP used...) and "no compression at all" (what you seem to be arguing against).
That's a good way to put it. I hate over-compressed music. It sounds terrible and is no fun to listen to once you notice the issue.
But, are you an audio engineer? I ask because I work in the field, and all engineers I know accept that dynamic range compression is a necessary part of creating recorded music. The problem is when you abuse compression to create a wall of noise with no dynamic range.
It's like autotune: you can use it to correct one bad note, or you can abuse it create T-Pain.
The engineers behind The Pixies and Nirvana [1], and all dubstep producers use or have used compression at various stages of the creative process.
[1] I guarantee you that whoever mixed Smells Like Teen Spirit spent a lot of time doing the compression on that song.