News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Not Even Twitter Understands Twitter by sowbug on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:31PM (#10522184)

  When you favorite a tweet, you mostly do so for your
  own consumption. It is a way for you to tell yourself
  that this tweet is something you want to get back to,
  or remember for later use.
That sure ain't how I use it. Two reasons. (1) Favorites are public. (2) I don't need to get back to a tweet or remember it for later use; they're short, so I remember them in my brain.

I saw the article was much longer, but the author lost me at that point.

Re:Not Even Twitter Understands Twitter by dsjoerg on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:57PM (#10522333)
Same here. Who is this Thomas Baekdal to tell me what I mean what I favorite a tweet?! Maybe that's why he does it, but how does he know about me?

I favorite a tweet to tell the tweeter that I liked what they said. I know they're gonna get an email saying I favorited their tweet.

I've totally forgotten that someone could use favoriting as a bookmarking system; I'm too busy to go back and look at lists of bookmarked tweets.

Re:Not Even Twitter Understands Twitter by to3m on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:17PM (#10522437)
This does seem to divide people. My own instant response to the favourite system was that it was obviously a means of expressing approval, without bombarding your followers' timelines with other people's stuff. "This tweet is a favourite of mine" = "I like this tweet". Eventually somebody favourited one of my tweets and I got an email telling me they'd done it, which just reinforced this idea for me.

Then after about 4 years somebody pointed out that it actually stored your favourites. And that meant you could use them as a kind of bookmark. Well! Who'd have thought? (I don't use Internet Explorer, which is my excuse for not spotting the favourite = bookmark connection.)

Re:Not Even Twitter Understands Twitter by tracker1 on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:47PM (#10522279)
Most of my tweets are things I find interesting, that I often look back to. If it's interesting to me, I'll retweet.

That's just me though, and I don't GAFF if it's public.

Re:Not Even Twitter Understands Twitter by delecti on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:37PM (#10522221)
"Favorite" sounds like a bookmark, but it behaved like a Facebook "like".

But the fact that its name sounded like a bookmark means lots of people used it that way anyway.

Re:Not Even Twitter Understands Twitter by mbillie1 on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:06PM (#10522379)
Given that one of the things you can easily do with Favorites is review a list of them, I think it's perfectly reasonable to say it behaved like a bookmark. I certainly used it for this purpose.
Re:Not Even Twitter Understands Twitter by delecti on Friday November 06, 2015 @09:29PM (#10523386)
Most bookmarks don't inform the site that you've bookmarked it, or let that site keep a very public counter of the number of bookmarks to it, or keep a public record of your bookmarks (delicious(however it was punctuated) not withstanding). It actually behaves very much like Tumblr's "Like" functionality in all of those regards.

I agree, it acted at least a little like a bookmark, but not more than it acted like a "like".