Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden
by will_pseudonym on Friday November 06, 2015 @01:00PM
(#10520839)
The ironic part is that the people who rail against Snowden in grabbing "everything" instead of only the "bad, important stuff" is exactly what Snowden is demonstrating that the government is doing! If they hate what Snowden did, why don't they hate what the government is doing in SECRET, to EVERYONE?
How does this argument even make sense? It is trivially possible to be angry at both the USG and Snowden.
Sure. But this is a great counter to the all-to-frequent dismissals framed as criticisms that Snowden should have done something more.
"Sure, I support valid whistle-blowers, but what Snowden did ..."
It's a simple way to show that to be hypocritical authoritarianism rather than valid criticism when they don't make the connection.
Your argument makes no sense; you could indeed say "The ironic thing about those supporting Snowden is that he grabbed "everything" instead of only the "bad, important stuf" which is exactly what they are complaining the government did.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden
by will_pseudonym on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:28PM
(#10521804)
Except governments are supposed to be accountable to their constituents. Had the government been transparent about what they were doing, there would be no need to blow the whistle in the first place, creating the need for Snowden to collect intelligence on the NSA's spying programs.
EDIT: It's victim blaming.
> I believe that some of what he leaked shouldn't have been,
Then blame your (government's) employees who left Snowden with no choice but to leak.
They essentially entangled classified data (their job) with unclassified data (the facts of their fraud).
He did actually have that option. If he had merely stolen and leaked information about two or three blatantly unconstitutional programs, which surely would have been very simple, I doubt quite so many people would be calling him a traitor. I certainly wouldn't.
Snowden did not have the option of leaking one or two things, then poring over data and leaking a few more. He had one shot to grab as much evidence as possible and flee the country. Given those constraints, I think his behavior was appropriate.
What is really to blame here is a system that made Snowden's method of revealing this data the best choice if you want to minimize your own chances of being tortured. Everyone who worked to ensure that complaints and dissatisfaction with mass surveillance were treated as traitors even before the Snowden leaks.