News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by Alupis on Friday November 06, 2015 @12:38PM (#10520679)
Frankly, Snowden is a Whistle-Blower by all definitions of the meaning. The US has some basic Whistle-Blower protections in place, which strongly motivates the government to flat-out deny any possible hint of it. Instead, the government has a large incentive to paint Snowden as a traitor, even if all evidence speaks to the contrary (nobody died from his leaks, nobody was in danger, it revealed capabilities all governments of the world already suspected and likely were attempting to guard against, he did not profit from it, he suffered at great personal detriment from the exposure, etc...)

John Oliver made a humorous analogy during his brief interview with Snowden.

When John Oliver framed the government domestic surveillance program as having the capability to intercept, store, and review your nude images (being sent to your partner, for example), it really made people upset.

However, when he framed it as being able to siphon all communications en masse, people essentially got the glazed-over look and stopped caring.

When presented with the fact that all that "nude image grabbery" and violations of personal privacy and freedoms has only resulted in a single "terrorist plot" being thwarted (that guy who gave money to a terrorist group and was promptly arrested)... people get very upset because the result certainly does not justify the cost.

It comes down to an understanding issue (or lack-thereof). Technical details bore most people, which makes them not care.

Another good analogy is the German Secret Police steaming open all letters, reviewing the contents, then re-sealing them and putting back into the mail stream. People think that's egregious, and that it would never happen in the US. But it clearly is...

These are certainly issues that majority of Americans are going to deeply care about - the trouble we have is how to communicate it in such a way as-to boil down and condense years of technical understanding in just a few words.

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by caskance on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:13PM (#10522075)
It's actually not an issue at all if, like John Oliver, you just care about making a point on a comedy program and don't care about being at all accurate. Snowden is a whistleblower who went far beyond the scope of responsible whistle blowing. That's why he is correctly seen as both a traitor and a hero.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by Alupis on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:03PM (#10522362)
> went far beyond the scope of responsible whistle blowing

Care to elaborate? Or just make snide comments without any factual content.

By definition, Snowden is a Whistle-Blower.[1][2][3][4]

Fact checks of Snowden's claims have largely been found to be very accurate.[5][6]

[1] http://whistleblower.org/what-whistleblower

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistleblower

[3] http://www.cpuc.ca.gov/PUC/Enforcement/whistleblowers.htm

[4] http://www.whistleblowers.gov/

[5] http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2015/apr/09/...

[6] http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2013/0...

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by tptacek on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:04PM (#10522371)
Nobody is arguing that Snowden disclosed things that were false. The argument is that not everything he disclosed was in the public interest.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by Alupis on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:16PM (#10522433)
I find it difficult to hold that argument to any light.

Yes, US foreign relations were damaged as part of the release - but how can anyone claim it's OK to subvert US companies efforts to do business in good faith with foreign customers? Or to wire-tap our closest allies? What about the fallout in pursuit of Snowden where US government officials technically invaded the sovereign nation of Bolivia (the Bolivian President's plane)?

Bringing it home, how is it OK to wire-tap our own elected officials? Or the entire city of Salt Lake? Parallel construction which put people in prison without a fair trail? Purposefully weakening or subverting security protections for every citizen?

Yes, it stung. However it was necessary, and absolutely in the public's best interest. These surveillance programs are very much out of control and scope. There is no sane argument to the contrary.

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by caskance on Monday November 09, 2015 @08:14AM (#10532819)
You can make anything sound nice if you couch it in vague enough terms. Spying on other countries is in fact, the entire point of the NSA. Domestic surveillance is not, and it was right to expose that. However, that does not excuse the things he inappropriately leaked any more than the NSA's lawful data collection excuses their unlawful programs.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by Alupis on Monday November 09, 2015 @10:43AM (#10533629)
What was inappropriately leaked?

You are making the argument that Snowden should have done nothing, when in fact that is the least moral thing to do in that situation.

The US is not some how "weaker" because of Snowden - it's weaker because of it's flagrant disrespect to all other nations in the world, especially our allies.

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by caskance on Monday November 09, 2015 @11:17AM (#10533851)
Information about foreign surveillance programs and details of NSA methods.

I never made such an argument. In fact, I have repeatedly stated what I think he should have done - reveal information about some obviously unconstitutional domestic surveillance - there's obviously no shortage of choices there.

Whether the US is weaker or stronger does not have anything to do with the question of whether Snowden broke the law. It might affect the judgment about whether he was justified in breaking the law, but that's something for the judge to decide during sentencing, or the president to decide when pardoning him. It's not an excuse for refusing to stand trial.

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by fineman on Saturday November 07, 2015 @08:48PM (#10527035)
Try putting systems in place to enable whistleblowing at an earlier level. You're punishing Snowden for your government not working.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by caskance on Monday November 09, 2015 @08:15AM (#10532822)
In fact, nobody is punishing him. He chose to flee the country to escape consequences for his actions.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by Alupis on Monday November 09, 2015 @10:40AM (#10533605)
Consequences were going to be a secret military trial where the death penalty was on the table.

He has stated many times he will come back and stand trial, so long as it's a fair public trial in civilian courts (because he was/is a civilian).

The US Gov't is unwilling to provide this more fair trial.

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by caskance on Monday November 09, 2015 @11:14AM (#10533829)
I think you're confusing Snowden with Manning. Snowden is not in the military and is not subject to UCMJ. Perhaps what you meant is that some evidence, being classified, would not be released to the public? That does go against what Snowden asked for, but there's nothing military about that. It's also IMO an unreasonable demand unless the information in question is a subset of what he already leaked, which is unlikely.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by fineman on Monday November 09, 2015 @01:09PM (#10534652)
Nope, the death penalty is definitely on the table based on the charges we've heard bandied about.

And the issue isn't that some evidence is classified, but that all evidence Snowden would want to present is classified. Even his motivation is based on works that are claimed to be classified.

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by caskance on Monday November 09, 2015 @04:57PM (#10536117)
I didn't say capital punishment was or wasn't on the table. I said it wasn't a military trial. Those are two completely orthogonal issues.

If Snowden can't present a single piece of evidence in his defense that isn't classified, I don't think he's got much of a case. Last I checked, the constitution isn't classified.

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by Alupis on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @10:37AM (#10539919)
Come off it.

You can't have a fair trial where 99% of the evidence is not allowed to be submitted.

The US has Whistle-Blower laws for a reason, yet the US Government is not allowing them to cover his case.

Until a guarantee of a free trial, he has stated he'll remain where he's at. And that's entirely reasonable.

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by caskance on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @11:29AM (#10540257)
Regardless of what Snowden thinks, evidence submitted doesn't have to be made public. Due to his contractor status, it's unclear which whistleblower protections would cover him, but that's something that can be established during trial. It's clear that Snowden and his supporters believe that a "fair" trial means one where he's exonerated. That's unreasonable.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by Alupis on Tuesday November 10, 2015 @01:20PM (#10541195)
You clearly have not been following the entire story. Selective facts don't tell the entire narrative.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by caskance on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @09:32AM (#10546814)
I'm pretty sure I know more than you do here, but I'll humor you. What facts do you think I'm missing?
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by fineman on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:43PM (#10550766)
Then you'd know it's not that the evidence presented at trial would remain sealed but that he wouldn't even be able to present it.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by caskance on Thursday November 12, 2015 @01:31PM (#10555108)
That's within the context of it being a trial open to the public.
Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by Alupis on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:18PM (#10556550)
> That's within the context of it being a trial open to the public.

Which the US Government is not allowing. We've looped back to the beginning here... and you still don't understand, don't accept, or don't know the entire narrative.

Re:Five hours with Edward Snowden by fineman on Thursday November 19, 2015 @05:33PM (#10598186)
No, he won't be able to present evidence at any trial. It's much more than keeping some testimony sealed.