To further extend the analogy, it would be like announcing the donut shop in a forum where people are talking about free food. Then being baffled when people took that to mean tha the donuts would be free.
When explaining one's rationale for locking down information, people often use metaphors of physical objects. This is doomed to fail. Try to use non-physical objects that are similar in nature to information as metaphors instead. The problem with that is of course that it is also impossible, as the very nature information shares with intangible goods is that they also want to be free.
Someone worked hard to produce that article and if they want to charge for it it's their right to.
In your example, the employer buys time, not information. Time is significantly harder to reproduce or copy than information is.
So, one way to charge for information is to sell time sensitive information (like stock information), but then what you're really selling is time exclusivity.
Selling information without any kind of unique or time sensitive properties is doomed to fail — the only thing that made it once possible was technical limitations; information needed for instance paper as a vehicle to distribute it. Those technical limitations are gone now.