That is, make it free for every user until that user reaches a certain level of influence. That way, you can grow without charging anything and then charge those who a) value it the most and b) have the money & reason to pay to sustain their influence.
Why can't Twitter create a pricing model for everyone with over 1m followers?
Why can't Facebook keep its service free for consumers but charge organizations?
The massive power of huge social followings (organic reach--without ads) is worth so much but valued at ZERO by social networks. I think it's a huge missed opportunity that is resulting in diminished value for everyone.
Total revenue would be lower, yes, but that should be matched by cost-cutting. These companies' head-counts are bloated compared to the services they offer.
I know there's a lot more to Twitter than the simplistic short-messaging system it seems to be from the outside (speed, scaling, etc)...but does it really need over 4,000 people to run it? I highly doubt it.
If this was the same for car sales, why would anyone recommend cars?
My own preferred model for charging would be the transferrable 'premium' account: essentially a visible flag on the account that anyone can pay for, like reddit gold. Encourage people to pay for accounts that they enjoy following.
If that idea is successful, they could let verified users limit their twitstream to show only Verified users.
Then, perhaps, you might stop seeing most of the random crap posted by trolls, who can mob you today, even if they don't follow you and you don't follow them.
Under what I was suggesting, you would still be able to follow whoever you liked, whether verified or not. However, you would be able to block all the unverified users....
But that is exactly how Facebook works: they charge organizations money to reach relevant users. Users are never charged.
In a perfect world, there wouldn't be any advertising on Facebook. Just billions of people using it for free, subsidized by companies that pay to be on it.
Without paying it's impossible to get your message out to your page fans, it doesn't work that way for long time anymore.
You'd essentially be creating an incentive to not gain popularity - I suspect that would stifle any kind of large-scale adoption.
At minimum it has to be free to get started, with the payment happening later as an add-on or up-sell. App.net put the payment up front, you couldn't use it until you paid, with the (predictable) result that nobody used it.
The model to look at is probably the tawdry world of "free-to-play" gaming on mobile, sadly.
I don't know if this is deliberate irony or just something that wasn't thought through very well...
Is it not possible to create a social network where the product is the social network? Perhaps not. App.net attempted this, and wasn't able to generate enough money to both keep the lights on and pay its employees.
As someone who once founded a company that published game books, I'm acutely aware of the fact that people are rarely willing to buy content in this age of free information. So what, then, would make them willing to pay to be a part of a social network?