News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by matthewbauer on Thursday November 05, 2015 @05:39AM (#10512634)
Does anyone else feel like they're just duplicating all the work done by Nix? I guess there's nothing wrong with multiple functional package managers. It just seems wrong to reject Nix just because it allows unfree software.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by rekado on Thursday November 05, 2015 @05:49AM (#10512660)
The Guix project reuses the Nix daemon but it made different decisions at various points, such as using one unified language (Guile Scheme) for every part of the system, or how to configure the system; using Guile for everything (turning Guix into a regular Scheme library) has given rise to different tools and projects that use the library.

The problem space is the same but there is not just one valid approach, even when we both decide on sticking to functional package management.

I love Scheme, so working on Guix is a no-brainer for me, but also other decisions of the Guix project align more with my priorities, such as the desire to not let blobs (e.g. for bootstrapping Java) sneak in needlessly. The absence of non-free software is a feature, in my opinion.

Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by civodul on Thursday November 05, 2015 @05:51AM (#10512663)
Guix indeed has a strong commitment to user freedom, which makes it a different project.

Technically, I don't see it as "duplicating" Nix: Guix uses low-level parts of Nix that are awesome, and replaces higher-level layers with a more integrated and unified system. See https://arxiv.org/abs/1305.4584 for the technical rationale or the video on the home page on the concrete impact of those differences. Hacking GuixSD is a very different experience, I think!

(Disclaimer: I maintain Guix and I'm a former NixOS hacker.)

Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by thinkpad20 on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:49PM (#10516944)
Does the Guix team have any interest in adding documentation to the Nix source code? Presumably you guys know a lot more about it than the average developer. I haven't spent a huge amount of time looking through the Nix source, but the times when I've had, I've found the documentation to be very anemic.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by mbrock on Thursday November 05, 2015 @07:32AM (#10512930)
Random lazy question: do you know about running GuixSD on AWS EC2? We're very happy with NixOS's AMI images, since they let us provision AWS instances extremely easily.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by civodul on Thursday November 05, 2015 @07:45AM (#10512967)
As far as I know nobody has tried so far, but that would be cool.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by mbrock on Thursday November 05, 2015 @05:48AM (#10512654)
I feel like all the Linux distributions are duplicating work. And all the language-specific package managers. If everyone could just get along and work on the same thing... Well, they're not going to. Guix has a different language, different core values, different allegiances, probably different long-term plans.

If I were to start thinking more seriously about the wasted effort in duplicated definitions of packages, I would probably end up thinking about using RDF linked data to define software dependencies and capabilities. Then you could generate Nix expressions, Guix things, RPMs, Docker containers, or what have you. The declarative model of Nix/Guix should work well with something like that.

Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by sparkie on Thursday November 05, 2015 @02:37PM (#10515649)
I hope you're not thinking of using Turtle or XML for defining packages in this system, as I would need to fork your project and define my packages in JSON-LD. I would also need to submit a proposal to the w3c to include 'rdf:SchemeLiteral' into the standard for compatiblity with existing infrastructure.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by mbrock on Thursday November 05, 2015 @02:44PM (#10515683)
Luckily the W3C people have been very careful to make sure that Turtle, XML, and JSON-LD are all interoperable, so I don't mind your fork, if the JSON syntax is more appropriate for your needs.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by digi_owl on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:53AM (#10512821)
It may help to look at it akin to evolution.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by emj on Thursday November 05, 2015 @08:25AM (#10513138)
If only more people mutated thei package managers..
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by sdegutis on Thursday November 05, 2015 @09:47AM (#10513563)
GNU seems like the China of software. They write their own version of all existing tools, simply so they can have a copy of it that completely adheres to their principles.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by taylanub on Thursday November 05, 2015 @12:16PM (#10514587)
I think that's a good thing when the principles are worth it. :-)
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by sdegutis on Thursday November 05, 2015 @01:14PM (#10515064)
I understand and respect that position. In the specific cases of both China and GNU though, I think the principles are misguided and naive.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by preid24 on Thursday November 05, 2015 @01:26PM (#10515160)
Would you say the same about the BSDs, who have rewritten software because it was under the GPL?
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by sdegutis on Thursday November 05, 2015 @01:51PM (#10515331)
I understand and respect their position too, and while I think it's probably a waste of time and effort, I think they're a little less misguided than the GPL group. I use both GPL and BSD tools every day, so I'm mostly indifferent.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by civodul on Friday November 06, 2015 @09:19AM (#10519541)
Free software aims to safeguard the freedom and autonomy of computer users. I think these are important features.
Re:GNU Guix 0.9.0 released – Functional package manager and ... by panglott on Thursday November 05, 2015 @08:27AM (#10513148)
I use Nix on Mac OS X, but would probably use Guix on Linux since it uses Scheme. I suspect they're complementary.