Contact Host allows you to send an enquiry to the host and is in no way a booking request. You should always do this before committing to a booking to ensure the place is actually available.
Request to Book commits you to a booking and your card is charged there and then, regardless of if the host accepts your request. It then takes up to 7 days to get your money back if the host declines - pretty frustrating.
Instant Book means the host can't decline your booking without their search ranking score being negatively affected.
1) Enter dates
2) Pick Place
3) Pick "Contact Host"
4) Host says place is as available
5) Get message from AirBnB saying I've been approved by host
6) Get message from AirBnB saying host has charged my card
At no time did I pick "Request a Booking". I thought it would stop at #5 and I'd have to then login to AirBnB to finalize the details but no, the host was able to do that without me even though I never picked "Request a Booking"(source: I'm both a host and traveller on Airbnb)
Have been using AirBnB for stays since 2012 and hosting since 2014. Never had an un-requested booking.
+ Host does not have a way to charge you
Or if you're from AirBnB, give me a fake account and all make it happen again. If you think this is how it works I'm telling you there's a bug in your system
It doesn't quite commit to you to a booking: at any point before the host accepts the request, you can cancel the request penalty-free [1]. So if you find something better in the meantime and change your mind on the AirBnB place, you can just cancel. It is however a bit risky, since there's always a chance that the host will accept RIGHT as you were about to go cancel. And having two requests outstanding bears the risk that you'll get unlucky, and they'll both accept so close together that you have no time to cancel the other one.
[1] https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/90/can-i-cancel-my-reser...
Airbnb should really build a quick-response app for hosts with a fat button for instantly denying a booking. Make it so that it's trivial to see a request and confirm/deny. Give the ability for renters to set a timeout on their requests too, or queue them up.
One of the most recent times I tried Airbnb in Venice, CA, I gave up and found something on VRBO that was cheaper and quickly available.
AirBnB has "instant booking" for like 10% of listing but for all the rest you click "request to book" and you've instantly committed to giving the host 24 hours to respond. If they respond in the positive you're booked. In other words, once you pick one place you're on the hook for it. You can't go looking for other places just incase the host says their place is not available.
Worse, the UX has 2 buttons "Request to Book" and "Contact Host". THEY DO THE SAME THING!!!! If you click "Contact Host" it will just send a booking request. The host can charge your credit card even though you only clicked "Contact". How do I know? It just happened to me