Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See
by billswift on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:55PM
(#1051109)
And they would be dead now even if no one had killed them back then. And those that killed them are all dead now. And no doubt more Amerindians were killed by other Amerindians over the centuries than ever had any contact at all with Europeans.
This is like all the whining about slavery. Slavery has been one of the most widespread practices in the world. Europeans were the ones who have come closest to putting a stop to it. And in fact it is only European derived morality that makes slavery and genocide wrong.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See
by moorej on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @10:04PM
(#1051815)
It's true many western enlightenment thinkers wrote wholeheartedly against slavery. However, they rarely, if ever, were actually referring to the actual slaves in their midst. Instead most of the intellectual discourse surrounding slavery concentrated on rights for those who could vote (often a small section of the population). Was European morality at work when Leopold II destroyed half the population of Congo?
So essentially you are calling for anarchy?
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See
by armandososa on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @05:48PM
(#1051393)
Anarchy is the only logical and natural state of being, every other attempt to bring order to chaos is unnatural. Imho.
Some societal constructs seem to have benefits, though. I am happy that I don't have to carry a gun at all times and don't have to fight for my territory and my life every day.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See
by billswift on Thursday January 14, 2010 @07:50PM
(#1053971)
There's nothing inherently wrong with society - it's government, and modern societies' love affairs with them, that suck.
I hope you enjoy not ever interacting with anybody else, because as soon as you start up relations with some other person you are creating some form of social order. Add a few more people and soon you'll be electing a mayor.
Maybe you are trying to argue for something good, but dead people are dead. They don't benefit from a civilization that emerged a couple of decades later.