News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by themilkmandan on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:56PM (#1050950)
Yes, all this black-or-white talk about genocide misses a lot of the subtleties. How about a nuanced analysis of the Jewish Holocaust? Nobody brings up enough the fact that Hitler built some damn good roads.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by seldo on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:59PM (#1050957)
You're missing the point. It's not that genocide is sometimes good, it's that civilizations that commit genocide also do good things.

The Germany that produced the Jewish holocaust also invented rocket science, which indirectly led us to the space program, satellites, and a big chunk of our modern communications network.

Does this excuse genocide? No. Does it make it difficult to label German civilization as "all good" or "all bad"? It absolutely does.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by ippisl on Thursday January 14, 2010 @06:21AM (#1052362)
I would label those technological advances in a different dimensions than moral acts. And usually the meaning of bad and good regards morals , not other fields of human behaviour.

And since as a nation their positive moral acts was so little relative to their negative moral actions you can call them "bad".

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by oconnor0 on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:05PM (#1050980)
True, and the article is a little simplistic on that front, but a modern communications network does not morally justifies the holocaust. Neither does making lots of money & whatever else the Unobtainium was going to do justify wholesale slaughter & genocide of the Na'vi.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by seldo on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:12PM (#1050999)
But that's exactly what I said. It doesn't excuse the holocaust. But it also makes it hard to say that Germany in the 1940s was an evil regime that contributed nothing to the world. Both are true: they were evil bastards, and they gave us rocket science. The real world is tricky like that.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by borism on Thursday January 14, 2010 @04:12AM (#1052237)
And I thought rocket science was invented by chinese (like pretty much everything else).
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by tfh on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:03PM (#1050970)
>The Germany that produced the Jewish holocaust also invented rocket science..

You get into trouble by saying that in Germany my friend :)

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by mahmud on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @09:41PM (#1051787)
Today's Germany is a fictitious entity, a comedic prop setup by a philosophe prankster.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by IsaacSchlueter on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:10PM (#1050993)
You missed the point, and then made exactly the error I was pointing at. And you did so in a way that gets very close to Godwin's Law without quite invoking it. Nicely done.

I'm not suggesting that Hitler's good roads made the holocaust less bad. I'm suggesting that the Holocaust didn't make the good roads less good.

Things aren't either all good or all bad. That includes the Conquistadors, Hitler, the Nazis, your children, a puppy, the Na'vi, the Native Americans, and everyone else.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by bobbyi on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:39PM (#1051076)
Can you quote the portion of the article that you interpret as saying that Western civilization has never done anything good?
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by catzaa on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:25PM (#1051038)
The world is a lot more complex than that. Germany was not treated well after the First World War. It was almost certain that there will be another war and a dictator would come to power (the only question was when, and what the dictator's name would be).

This does not mean that everything the German army did was good or justified (e.g. the Holocaust). And neither was the allies knights in shining armour (firebombing of Dresden and Tokyo comes to mind).

My grandparents (although not German citizens) were fiercely supportive of Germany in WW2, as where many people. This stemmed mostly from the UK’s treatment of people in its colonies.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by billswift on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @04:01PM (#1051128)
You mean after the First World War. That's why I argued elsewhere that Woodrow Wilson deserves a big chunk of the blame for the rise of Nazi Germany, maybe even more than Hitler, since without his meddling in Europe during the Great War Hitler quite possibly would never have gotten anywhere.