ASP.Net MVC, is very subjective. It definitely is very 'weird' from the perspective of being on a static language platform but embracing 'magic' over standard type safety.
I will give you routing though, i dont really think it 'sucks' but i have lead development teams using MVC for years... whenever a new developer who isnt familiar comes on board, the most significant 'learning curve' is the routing... i am not really a fan myself but i understand what the value proposition is...
I can be civil till certaint point, but how to be more civil when you have no idea of what you are talking about and instead of admiting it you just keep making more ignorant statemens?, just say "I have no clue" and that's it, nobody is going to judge you.
>the fact remains that the default routing system is fairly mediocre, for no particular reason
You keep repeating the same as a broken record, yet, you have presented zero evidence, there is no route that I have implemented in Java that I wasn't able to replicate in the same way or even more easily in .NET, be it MVC or Web Api, so please, present some evidence or go home.
Just decent? I dissagree, it is the best language to my taste.
>NET MVC, though, is far from impressive
Tell me what is impressive them, becuase to me is a well stablished, easy to use and learn with static typing, there is nothing better.
>The routing is crap
The routing is highly configurable, by default it mimics Ruby on Rails routing and if you don't like it you can use your own, you have no idea of what are you talking about.
>Razor is designed to encourage you to dump C# straight into your views
Just like in JSP pages you can write Java code, or in ERB pages you can write Ruby code or in EJS pages yu can write JavaScript code, and if you don't like there a re plenty of options.
>which I really don't see as the future of web development
Your personal views are just that, personal, at least inform your self well before making ignorant statements.
As is yours, so why bicker?
C#/.NET is also my favourite, but it's not the be-all and end-all of web development. It might be the best for all of your projects, but not for everyone else.
It has it's flaws, like everything else, and I'm happy for you that you haven't used it (or anything else) for long enough to discover them.
And if you like functional programming, use F#. It's pretty great.