I could certainly see how both theories would have attracted some disbelief in their time. In Einstein's case, people started to accept SR when new experimental results came that only made sense if the speed of light were constant and the laws of physics were invariant in all inertial reference frames.
Why do we have to accept that something novel is happening in this case? Can you find any way to explain this effect with existing theory? More importantly, what would have to be changed to accommodate this phenomenon? Is it possible that the engineers are just measuring noise?
These are important questions that have to be answered.
In this instance, we have a device which is proposed to work by means that violate basic laws of conservation. There is no accompanying theory for why that is. It has been tested by several groups, and as these groups improve their testing methodology, the resultant "thrust" decreases. That is not promising. If the effect under test decreases as experimental rigor goes up, then the default assumption should be there is probably nothing there.
Of that we can be sure
The good thing is that "Of course it doesn't work" has not gotten anyone a Nobel price
And it may even not violate conservation of momentum
Your argument is the same as those made around relativity, as it disagreed with Newton, and what could some fucking patent clerk possibly know that the Greatest Scientist Ever didn't?