It needs to be almost absolutely undeniable that this drive works, not a mere suspicion or curiosity.
"IF scientists universally adopted your position [...]"
Scientists don't universally adopt positions, so that's not something we have to worry about. We have to worry about non-scientists adopting dreams over facts.
But really, there's no point in declaring victory or defeat while the battle is still going.
The question is really one of priority: how much effort should we put into chasing down each potential new result?
For some questions we spend staggering amounts of effort--think of the Hubble Deep Field images, proposed gravity wave observatories, neutrino observatories, and the Large Hadron Collider. We predicted the Higgs, but we still spent billions of dollars to go confirm that!
In contrast, we're spending a very small amount--just a couple people with a small budget--to investigate things like the Elcubierre "warp drive" and the "Emdrive." And we spend basically nothing to investigate things that are obviously fake.
It seems proportionate to me.
But, see, if we follow the approach of the doubters here, we'll never get to almost absolutely undeniable evidence, because we won't bother to investigate it because of how improbable it is.
Look, people here are saying that an incomplete theory is possible - not certain, not even probable, just possible. It's happened twice in just over a century, so, yeah, not probable. But saying that it can't happen because the science is settled is, ironically, not a very scientific approach.
> But really, there's no point in declaring victory or defeat while the battle is still going.
Absolutely.
Same thing here. This is not likely to be new physics. But if it is, the payoff is high enough to make it worth looking at seriously.
Note well: This does not mean "start doubting all of physics until we disprove this". It means, yes, it's worth it to have a team at NASA spend some time trying to figure out what's going on. And even if they don't find new physics, they're going to learn something about an error factor to control for, which, among other things, might shed some light on the Pioneer anomaly.
I would not bet enough to cover a team of NASA engineers spending their time on it.
The history of science is full of unexplained experimental errors that were later confirmed by an improved theory (see Einstein's General Theory of Relativity vs Newton's 'Law' of gravitation).
IF scientists universally adopted your position, then there wouldn't have been any point in further investigating experimental contradictions (time dilation, gravitation lensing) to Newton's Laws since they were clearly impossible based on the REALLY REALLY well tested laws of physics.