I'm not really sure how to fix this, or if it should be fixed. Is it a problem that I can't get phone service without agreeing to give up my right to a class action? It seems that it is: it allows companies to essentially have one sided contracts. I must abide by the rules of the contract or be taken to arbitration (where I will lose), but the company can feel free to break the contract whenever they wish. If I complain, we will go into arbitration and I will lose.
I suppose the way to fix it is to put legal controls on arbitration, but if enough controls are put on arbitration, it starts to look a lot like court, at which point, the value of arbitration has been lost. However, at the moment, the lack of controls make outright fraud much too easy.
Here is a question: can you sue the arbiter for a bad decision? It seems this idea isn't unheard of[0], but it is definitely not perfect.
Happens with employment contracts all the time around sexual harassment and workplace disputes. It's not to say it's unreasonable though. Disputes are common and court is expensive while arbitration is usually cheaper and more efficient.
Honestly, the bigger concern is contract signing practices more so than arbitration. I'm 100% for people or businesses being able to sign a contract with an agreement between them for just about anything, from buying a house to getting married.
The problem is the way contracts are presented. "The fine print" is meant to be something huge and intimidating enough that you won't take the time to read it. Lawyers are expensive and in most situations you're not going to have one read every single contract that you're presented with.
I went to lease a vehicle a couple of years ago. Talked to the sales person, sat at their desk, filled out a bunch of paperwork, sat and waited while he stepped out of the office to do something with it. After I'd been waiting for about an hour he comes back in with a huge stack of paperwork for me to sign.
At this point a few things can happen:
A) I spend 2-3 hours pouring over every one of the documents, asking him specific questions about wording, to which he'll call his manager to get an answer, etc potentially dragging on for hours before finally reaching an agreement.
B) I ask to have my attorney look at the documents, taken them and leave. He will review them when he gets free and in a couple of days send me his concerns. I will then pass them back along to the sales person who will pass it on to a manager who will either approve or escalate it to their own attorney. At the end of this process, assuming everything can be worked out I will PROBABLY lease the vehicle assuming it's still on the lot. I will then get a bill from my attorney.
C) I will rush through and sign the documents, trusting the business not to screw me, simply because I'm tired of waiting and want to get out of there.
All of these are a problem and the result is usually C "just sign the damn contract"
At some point, we need to establish some legal rules around SIZE of contracts and the strength of those agreements. Under scenario B where each party has an attorney involved and gets the details worked out to exactly the terms everyone is happy with a contract should be borderline ironclad.
Under scenario A or C where an attorney wasn't involved and the signing process was engineered to produce a signature, significantly more leeway needs to be given to the terms of that contracts and/or the penalties for breaking it.
That's one of the great things about working in Right to Work states because even the most ironclad of noncompete agreements are basically unenforceable in all but the most specific of circumstances.