News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by dtf on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @08:33AM (#1050073)
What is this, an episode of Lie To Me? :-)

Government spies in the Shanghai office stealing Google's source tree seems to have been the straw that broke the camel's back. I guess China will just build their own Google now...

Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by andreyf on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @10:10AM (#1050228)
Government spies in the Shanghai office stealing Google's source tree seems to have been the straw that broke the camel's back. I guess China will just build their own Google now...

The NYT article explicitly says the opposite: "attackers may have succeeded in penetrating elaborate computer security systems and obtaining crucial corporate data and software source code, though Google said it did not itself suffer losses of that kind". In general, that's not the language I hear them using - "broad", "sophisticated", and "targeting infrastructure of a variety of major corporations".

Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by gwern on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:12PM (#1050835)
FWIW, Wikileaks is saying that they were 'infiltrating' the Google repos: http://twitter.com/wikileaks/ (and specifically http://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/7688415363 ). The NYT is simply parroting Google, so I give Wikileaks more credence.

(Colloquially, you can be 'stealing' something while haven't yet actually absconded with it yet, and be foiled if discovered.)

Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by wrs on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:12PM (#1050997)
Wikileaks: "Several rumours from google sources that China accessed google's US-gov intercept system which provides gmail subjects/dates"

I'm remembering recent news about convenient gov't web portals to telecom records...

Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by Estragon on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @09:16AM (#1050147)
Yeah, this guy's been watching too much TV.

I've trained with Ekman's METT and SETT programs, and I didn't interpret his facial cues the same way. Those expressions looked like anger and sadness to me.

Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by andreyf on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @09:40AM (#1050180)
Anger and sadness are certainly there, and with good reason. But the tension during some answers and not during others is there, as well. Not because he's lying, but because he's making sure not to say something he is not allowed to. The pre-rehearsed part about not claiming the attack to have been state-sponsored is a good control - the anger/sadness is there, but the tension is not.
Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by scott_s on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @11:05AM (#1050354)
A corporate spokesperson giving an interview on television is nothing but an exercise in avoiding saying things that are not "allowed." It could just be that the times when you see tension is that those weren't scripted questions, and he had to come up with a response on the spot. The questions where he was more relaxed could be questions they anticipated, and had already formulated answers for.
Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by andreyf on Friday January 15, 2010 @02:23AM (#1054445)
Right, I'm asking "when is he saying things close to that which is not allowed?", and "when is he saying things unrelated to what is unallowed?". For example, when he talks about the distinction between the attacks on GMail and the malware on user machines, he's very comfortable, even though he's clearly off-script. When he's talking about Google's desire to stay in China, he's downright confident.
Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by Estragon on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @11:11AM (#1050368)
Even if he were especially tense during those moments (and I'm not seeing it, relative to his tension throughout the interview), your interpretation is a huge stretch from a tiny piece of data. There are many alternative explanations. The moments you cite are exactly those where he's laying down google's gauntlet. He was on national TV, claiming that it is no longer possible to do business with a powerful nation because its representatives have been suppressing opponents to its totalitarian policies with highly illegal and unethical tactics. I would be pretty tense under those circumstances, too. Every person of Chinese descent I met after that, I would be wondering what they think of me.
Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by andreyf on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @07:31PM (#1051603)
your interpretation is a huge stretch from a tiny piece of data

Did you read the article? That's exactly why I source the NYT and Google's blog for more data - I'm not saying I read that this was a broad attack against 34 international corporations spanning nearly all major industries because they guy flinched one way or another, I'm saying I noticed him flinch (without the sounds on) on questions which happen to also be half-truths by the content of his blog post.

Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by Estragon on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @08:47PM (#1051720)
Yes, your argument was a non sequitur. Just because they were also apparently targeting industrial espionage, it doesn't follow that dissidents weren't "clearly targeted." Both of the Drummond quotes you highlight are completely in line with your subsequent analysis.
Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by andreyf on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @09:06PM (#1051740)
it doesn't follow that dissidents weren't "clearly targeted

Right. Half-truths meaning "these are not lies, yet they aren’t something Drummord is completely comfortable about, either". I'm saying his statements are true, but only a minor part of the whole picture - that this was a much bigger attack, and Chinese dissidents were a minor target.

Re:Google's half-truths, and a plea for perspective by Estragon on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @09:50PM (#1051799)
Yes, and now we're back to the "huge stretch" I claimed before.