News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by pjc50 on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @04:56AM (#10498513)
The UK had capital controls until the 1970s. I see the GBP far up there on the opposite side of the chart; presumably that represents all the money rushing into the property bubble.

I'm coming round to the belief that the big downside of free movement of goods/people/capital is the possibility of "sloshing": rapid change that capsizes the economy. Entire areas can dry up or become booms overnight. And because there isn't and can't be free movement of real estate to compensate, we get craziness in the property market.

Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by leohutson on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @05:48AM (#10498686)
Excess isolationism also makes the economy more vulnerable. For example, primary industries are more exposed by gluts in production flooding the market and driving down the value of goods, and shortages of domestically produced goods will obviously have a more severe impact on consumers.

Obviously no protectionist scheme is going to tax goods that it's market cannot produce, but there is always a tendency to put industry above consumer, and assymetric/mercantile style protections in place.

People often have intellectual debates about ideology/philosophy here, but nationalism is the real political force. If a government can be seen to steer its economy in the right direction, and its people feel well off compared to their neighbours, it will be popular, regardless of ideology, and regardless of how fairly it has treated other nations in trade negotiations.

Likewise, a state will inevitably favor free trade when it will profit over other states, and protectionism when it won't.

In the rare case when both states will benefit from an arrangement, there's usually some third party getting screwed, i.e.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OPEC

I'm conflating capital controls with trade, but my point is more that they are often negotiated at the same time, and in the with the same ultimately selfish and unideological outlook.

Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by keithpeter on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @05:08AM (#10498546)
How much damping is needed to stop the sloshing but still allow 'organic' free trade, the kind of free trade that lets industries build up but without the short term bubbles?

An aside UK property at the low end: the move from HA/Council rents to private rents (i.e. from around 350 to 750 per month outside the Great Wen) is going to make the current debate about livable wage interesting. Some Tories already coming round to rent cap/build for controlled rent.

Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by crdoconnor on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @06:06AM (#10498759)
>I'm coming round to the belief that the big downside of free movement of goods/people/capital is the possibility of "sloshing"

High capital flows do correlate with frequency and severity of financial crises:

http://www.voxeu.org/article/ez-crisis-and-historical-trilem...

This is why poorer countries tend to enact capital controls. Foreign capital has a tendency to flee all at the same time (for a safe haven like America), which is ruinous for the economy. There's something of a feedback loop there.

This is why some investors describe emerging markets as markets from which it is difficult to emerge in an emergency.

Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by kspaans on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @06:19AM (#10498798)
I've seen this article repeated in the NatPo[0], and more-or-less copied in the HuffPo[1], but no where else. I suspect this is mostly fearmongering. The US market is so much bigger than Canada's that most investment portfolio recommendations for Canadians include double-digit proportions of US equities and bonds. And if they are weighted towards energy, I can see why they'd shift south of the border.

0 - http://business.financialpost.com/investing/global-investor/...

1 - http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2015/11/02/canada-economy-manuf...

Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by branchless on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @07:23AM (#10499063)
Where would the UK be without selling off large swathes of our land which is impoverishing our people? What will they do when we have no more of interest to sell?
Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by osullivj on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @05:16AM (#10498564)
Yes - the abolition of exchange controls was one of the first things Margaret Thatcher did when she became PM in May 1979.
Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by Retric on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @10:14AM (#10500046)
Property taxes are a great way to pop a real estate bubble.
Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by arethuza on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @07:39AM (#10499150)
"all the money rushing into the property bubble"

That would make quite a nice animated visualisation.

Re:Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed... by escherplex on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @12:03PM (#10500835)
There's a simple exploding bubble animation on western European maritime power ebbs and flows during the last two centuries which you may enjoy, here:

URL: https://vimeo.com/6437816