News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Top 1% now owns more of the wealth than the remaining 99% by fsloth on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:13PM (#10493197)
There are some statistical studies that show that in completely free market most of the wealth gets accrued on a few individuals. I.e. the population generates the wealth but only a few gain maximum benefits for a statistical fluke and no specific high performance input of their own. The question is - do we want to modify the free rules with income balancing or not. It's not about in the larger context about should a few pay money from their own pockets for the many - with the statistical view it all never was theirs in the first place. Economies which redistribute all wealth are probably quite inefficient. Economiea which do not redistribute are quite unfair. There's a sweet spot between these two extremes.
Re:Top 1% now owns more of the wealth than the remaining 99% by afsina on Monday November 02, 2015 @02:02PM (#10494169)
I do not think there is a sweet spot, or better to say you cannot stop in the sweet spot. Once you start redistribution, it never stops growing. Governments use social welfare as a bribe for votes. Every election new and larger benefits are introduced to overcome the overly generous competition. Taxes goes higher with different forms. Government hires more and more people. The more nationalization you make the more taxes you collect. Investment, profit and culture of entrepreneurship diminishes So you deviate from the hypothetical sweet spot quite fast. What comes sure next is economical depression.
Re:Top 1% now owns more of the wealth than the remaining 99% by fsloth on Monday November 02, 2015 @02:17PM (#10494310)
"Once you start..."

I don't think there is any civilized government that does not perform redistribution. Taxes are a form of redistribution. Any government functions such as free schooling, are a one way to redistribute the wealth back to society.

Re:Top 1% now owns more of the wealth than the remaining 99% by afsina on Monday November 02, 2015 @04:23PM (#10495369)
My claim is that all governments tend to grow by social means and populism. This may be slow or fast. After a point, prosperity disappears and slowly impoverishment starts.
Re:Top 1% now owns more of the wealth than the remaining 99% by fsloth on Monday November 02, 2015 @04:46PM (#10495522)
This sounds to me as an overestimatation of populism as a political force against against defenders of vested inteterests and capital.

Political institutions can and do decay but not all of them so this is not a general rule. As an example, Britain, Sweden, Switzerland have quite old governmemts and they are among the most prosperous countries in the world. When speaking of redistribution of wealth sweden has taken it as far as it can in economic terms and they seem to be going strong ahead - it seems they balance social and business needs quite well.