News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by thehodge on Monday November 02, 2015 @11:48AM (#10492942)
Hopefully this will be a look forward beyond Voyager rather than going back again..
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by drunken-serval on Monday November 02, 2015 @11:51AM (#10492968)
Personally, I don't see anything wrong with going for an alternate timeline and a modern take on starship design. As long as they don't turn Star Trek into an action franchise, I'm okay with it.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by cwyers on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:21PM (#10493288)
I've seen this said a lot, and I mean... the original Star Trek was a TV series in the late 60s, so in terms of what the effects were capable of on a TV budget and what standards and practices would allow, I think they were as action-oriented as they could be. The original run of Star Trek is filled with as many fistfights, space battles and fights to the death with the Vulcan Lirpa as the budget would allow. Trek was about much more than JUST action (Conscience Of The King is one of my favorite examples of this), but they did a lot of it.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by alexbecker on Monday November 02, 2015 @11:52AM (#10492982)
> As long as they don't turn Star Trek into an action franchise

Oh god, that would be tragic.

Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by ramblerman on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:03PM (#10493092)
Well that's pretty much what the last movie was.

That being said I thought it was quite good when you didn't think of it as 'star trek'

Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by aidenn0 on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:20PM (#10493272)
Yeah the two new movies were essentially action movies that captured the feel of the TOS characters.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by serge2k on Monday November 02, 2015 @08:46PM (#10496816)
Did they capture the feel?

Spock was okay at times. Kirk was okay at times. Scotty was comic relief, with very little of him being a badass

Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by rhino369 on Monday November 02, 2015 @01:07PM (#10493731)
All the movies except 1 and 4 were essentially action movies. And 4 was mostly a fish out of water comedy.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by ocdtrekkie on Monday November 02, 2015 @02:20PM (#10494356)
As much as it's often panned, Insurrection is the most Star Trek of Star Trek movies. It's about the Prime Directive at it's core. The Undiscovered Country is also a great example of a movie about diplomacy.

Sure, every movie is going to be action-packed for film screens, but those two I felt stuck to Star Trek's ideals more than the rest, where the movie focused on stopping a specific evil villain.

Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by rhino369 on Monday November 02, 2015 @05:35PM (#10495861)
It's been a while since I saw Insurrection and Undiscovered Country, but you could make a similar argument about Star Trek into Darkness. It was about the struggle between a militarized starfleet and a starfleet about discovery and exploration.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by ocdtrekkie on Monday November 02, 2015 @10:36PM (#10497300)
I honestly just feel Into Darkness is a movie about Khan. I've never felt the new Trek movies put out this discovery and exploration vibe. They certainly haven't attempted to do so as of yet.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by dangerboysteve on Monday November 02, 2015 @11:55AM (#10493008)
As long as it's not based on a truck rest stop like DS9.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by Aqwis on Monday November 02, 2015 @11:53AM (#10492991)
Unless they put it in the alternate timeline, which it doesn't sound like they will given this quote:

>The new television series is not related to the upcoming feature film Star Trek Beyond which is scheduled to be distributed by Paramount Pictures in summer 2016.

...they'd have to some serious retconning to place it anywhere before Voyager. Too much existing canon to take into account when writing the scripts.

Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by cmiles74 on Monday November 02, 2015 @11:59AM (#10493051)
Given they have the head writer from the last two movies, I can't see them sticking with the old, tired canon.

It could be that they need to be clear that they aren't associated with the next film. Different characters, etc.

Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by Amezarak on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:11PM (#10493178)
> Given they have the head writer from the last two movies, I can't see them sticking with the old, tired canon

What is "tired" about existing canon? What stops people from writing new stories with new characters in the "old" canon? How, for example, was Voyager burdened by the old, tired canon in TNG or DS9?

As best I can tell, the only reason they don't do it is because they would prefer to cash in on the popularity of the pre-existing characters and the pre-existing stories without actually having to write as though they exist.

Star Trek is a series based on exploration. There are plenty of new worlds and new peoples to see, without throwing away the old canon, while at the same time not relying on it very much.

I honestly can't understand why people like the idea of resets and reboots. To me, it just feels lazy and unsatisfying.

Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by cmiles74 on Monday November 02, 2015 @02:04PM (#10494198)
I can see where you are coming from and I acknowledge that my comment was cleary meant to denigrate "the canon" of older Star Trek works.

You may be right, a new team of writers may be able to author a new show that adheres to these stories and still comes off as fresh and exciting.

To my mind, the Voyager series (which I did enjoy) was meant to do what you recommend: use exploration of new worlds as a way to introduce new storylines and, to some degree, to distance the show from the storylines of the past. While I enjoyed that show, I don't think it was entirely successful. Specifically, it didn't appear to generate enough interest to warrrant more films, which seem to be what keeps this series alive.

The last series, Enterprise, seemed to be trying to accomplish the same goal by going back into the past, before many of these storylines took place. To my mind, it was wholly unsuccessful. I watched every episode and felt unsatisfied after the majority of them.

In my opinion, the failure of the last two series to generate enough interest for more films was a big reason why the "reboot" idea is more attractive.

Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by ocdtrekkie on Monday November 02, 2015 @03:07PM (#10494785)
Enterprise was just badly written for much of it's run. Season 4 was an excellent example of how Enterprise could've been done very well, but unfortunately it was way too late to save the show.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by ZanyProgrammer on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:36PM (#10493448)
That quote really doesn't explain anything, since they could put it in the 24th or 25th century in the new timeline, and not have it impact the upcoming movie.
Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by roneesh on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:01PM (#10493077)
Agree, please please please not a prequel!

The big joy of Star Trek is speculating about the future, in these times especially I think we could use more optimism about a future we haven't thought of yet, not just a dramatic retcon of stories we already know.

Re:New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017 by zo1 on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:13PM (#10493200)
I think they do this very deliberately. Short of making an alternate timeline, they'd have to "play-out" the universe we know as part of TNG/VOY/ENT/DS9.

Sure, they could leave it vague and have us all guessing what happened in those intermediate years, but that wouldn't be the StarTrek we know as we'd have no idea how they got to that point.

Also, they'd essentially lock themselves into an intermediate storyline that somehow leads to the universe they portray.

Hopefully ,if they do decide to make the setting "post" all the other shows by a long stretch of time, they work around some of these pitfalls and come up with a great story and addition to the franchise.