The later is harder to say, maps poorly between representational spacers (commas/dots depending), and is easy to confuse.
Keep in mind, before the 20th century, there wasn't much of a case where anybody would have to deal with figures this large, these days literally everybody does. Getting rid of two syllables and aligning the spoken form with the representational form greatly simplifies day-to-day speech.
The long scale is slightly more logical with its
(Latin number)illion = 10^(6 times Latin number)
(whatever)illiard = 1000 times (whatever)illion
, compared to the short scale's (Latin number)illion = 10^(3 times Latin number plus 3)
that somehow maps even Latin numbers to odd exponents and vice versa.If one could design this from a clean sheet, I think a short form where billion = 10^6, trillion = 10^9 would make the most sense, as it logically names numbers that one might encounter. Scientists who need huge numbers will use scientific notation or phrases such as gigadollars.
Since the words larger than thousand that are used most often (at this time) are million and milliard/billion, I like the way milliard is very different from million and at the same time, in French, follows a kind of natural progression from mille, million, milliard.
Larger numbers rarely need to be discussed outside contexts where you'd use scientific notation anyway.
When numbers on the order of 10^9 started to become a thing that needed to be discussed regularly, everybody grudgingly switched to the American short-scale "billion" on the grounds of it actually being useful.