News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by jsprogrammer on Sunday November 01, 2015 @03:06AM (#10485769)
Is there more to elaborate on? How else would one notify of a modified contract, but by producing the modified contract?

It is not the receiving party's responsibility to determine if something they receive is another party's form letter, or other spam-like.

Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by _delirium on Sunday November 01, 2015 @04:38AM (#10485936)
The usual process is to conspicuously red-line a contract, so your changes are clearly visible (traditionally, highlighted in red ink), along with a notification up front that you're sending back a revised contract.

From the article it's not entirely clear to me what form his modifications took:

> [He] scanned it into his computer, altered the terms and sent it back to Tinkoff Credit Systems.

By this do they mean he did something like "photoshop" the scanned contract, producing a result that looks as similar as possible to the original, but with some parts digitally modified? That would be a bit more misleading, if so.

Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by jsprogrammer on Sunday November 01, 2015 @01:32PM (#10487500)
My guess is that he wanted substantially similar terms, except for a few modifications. It's far easier to modify the existing contract than to write up an entire new one in that case. The other party still has the right of refusal. If they still do not wish to sign the contract after reading it, that is a choice available to them. If they choose to sign the contract without reading it...well...many people are bad at contracts...not the least of whom, are often banks.
Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by argonaut on Sunday November 01, 2015 @03:26AM (#10485797)
Obviously, none of us know what specific language he used in talking to the bank, and IANAL, but if the bank said something along the lines of "here's the contract we'd like you to sign", and he replied along the lines of "here's the contract I've signed that I'd like you to sign", it would be acting in bad faith to not tell the bank you've changed the contract.
Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by jsprogrammer on Sunday November 01, 2015 @01:56PM (#10487592)
A contract is not enforceable if it was not read by both parties accepting it. If banks don't read what they sign...fuck'em.
Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by argonaut on Sunday November 01, 2015 @04:51PM (#10488503)
Again, we don't know what actually happened, but presumably they read what they sent over to him.
Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by jsprogrammer on Sunday November 01, 2015 @09:33PM (#10489629)
Then there is no issue. They received notification.
Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by argonaut on Monday November 02, 2015 @03:46AM (#10490731)
They did not receive notification under the hypothetical scenario I described (the hypothetical scenario where he doesn't tell the bank that he changed the contract).
Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by jsprogrammer on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:35PM (#10493435)
So, they received the new text, read it, and accepted it, but they were never notified of the new text?

It seems like you are requiring some out-of-band signalling? What should the specs be for that other signalling mechanism?

Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by argonaut on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @04:49PM (#10510038)
Yes. Out of band signaling is required. Like saying in the email "I've changed the contract, here are the new terms."
Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by jsprogrammer on Thursday November 05, 2015 @05:59PM (#10516735)
I don't know of any banks that process CC contracts by email.

My guess is that he filled out the application forms, set the terms of the contract how he desired them, left a note on top of it all to the effect of, "BTW, I changed the terms, lol. You should probably read them.", stuffed it in an envelope and mailed it to the bank. A bank clerk probably received the envelope, looked to make sure the application form was filled out and the contract signed, then marked in the bank's database that the requisite documents had been received.

Re:Man who created own credit card sues bank for not stickin... by argonaut on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:55PM (#10522845)
Okay. But that's not the scenario I outlined. I made it clear that my points were referring to the scenario I outlined.