News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A lot of what we think we know about WWII is wrong by bsder on Sunday November 01, 2015 @01:27AM (#10485626)
> Americans fall for this too and feel bad about the nuclear bombing of Japan, despite the enormous good it did to the whole of south-east Asia.

We may feel bad with access to the information we have now, but, in interviews with people from that time, it's not so clear cut.

First, very few people really understood what a nuclear bomb was or could do. We're used to instantaneous communication. I seriously doubt we even had pictures in the US of Hiroshima before the Nagasaki bomb dropped.

Second, the US suffered terrible casualties in trying to retake Japanese islands before the bombs. Any effort to avoid that was welcome.

Third, people in the US were VERY tired of war. Anything which could bring that to a close sooner would be welcomed.

Fourth, the average person in both the US and Japan had no idea what the leaders were talking about or knew.

There are lots of What-If's? for not dropping the atomic bombs. However, there are just as many the other direction. One could just as easily point out that the hardline faction in Japan might have attempted a coup without the example of the devastation that the bombs caused and that it was the bombs that allowed the emperor to surrender.

Re:A lot of what we think we know about WWII is wrong by AnimalMuppet on Monday November 02, 2015 @08:05PM (#10496673)
> One could just as easily point out that the hardline faction in Japan might have attempted a coup without the example of the devastation that the bombs caused and that it was the bombs that allowed the emperor to surrender.

The hardline faction attempted a coup even with the example of the bombs.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surrender_of_Japan#Attempted_m...

Re:A lot of what we think we know about WWII is wrong by vacri on Sunday November 01, 2015 @04:10AM (#10485877)
Another angle is that in hindsight, it was probably a good thing that nuclear weapons were first used in their infancy. Fast forward a decade or two to the depths of the cold war - a lack of knowledge about the actual effects of bombs on cities might have made a larger exchange between the superpowers more likely.