Re:Why Tesla's Autopilot and Google's car are entirely diffe...
by ghaff on Saturday October 31, 2015 @03:49PM
(#10483923)
It's an interesting question in that properly maintained and properly driven automobiles do have accidents that are clearly no one's fault--skidding on a patch of ice, deer running into the road, etc. Perhaps a more skilled or more cautious driver could avoid such an accident--or not. I'm hard-pressed to think of many other examples where a product used as intended will nonetheless cause harm to the user or others with some finite probability--but aren't considered the fault of the manufacturer. Pharmaceuticals and other types of medical equipment probably come closest. (Though drug companies certainly face lawsuits for side effects all the time.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why Tesla's Autopilot and Google's car are entirely diffe...
by sokoloff on Saturday October 31, 2015 @04:41PM
(#10484116)
Chainsaws and handguns are probably other examples.
Fast food is another. (Alcohol, tobacco?)
Side note: I would argue that your patch of ice example is not nearly as good as the deer one. Skidding on a patch of ice and crashing is, IMO, simply driving too fast for conditions.
Re:Why Tesla's Autopilot and Google's car are entirely diffe...
by ghaff on Saturday October 31, 2015 @04:52PM
(#10484166)
Fast food etc. though is more "stuff that's bad for you taken to excess" as opposed to something that can randomly get in an accident though.
I agree the deer is the better example. You can have patches of unexpected black ice though. I've skidded a few times though never had an accident.
There's certainly gear one uses in activities that have some inherent danger like your chainsaw example. I guesxs things like skis and helmets could be another. The difference with an AI though is that it's the machinery itself that is making the decisions.