News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by mikeash on Saturday October 31, 2015 @02:58PM (#10483688)
I would argue that a prosecutor's job is not about guilt or innocence, and that it is to just convict people. Just like it's the defending attorney's job to get people acquitted, regardless of guilt or innocence. It is the court's role to convict guilty people and acquit innocent people, which in theory happens when you allow a prosecutor who wants to convict and a defending attorney who wants to acquit to argue in front of an impartial judge and jury.

In theory. It's a wacky system when you think about it and there's plenty of places it can fall down. But as built, I don't think it's the prosecutor's job to decide innocence or guilt.

They do need to follow the rules, though. If they're obtaining convictions by violating the rules, they need to be punished strongly. If they're obtaining false convictions within the rules then the rules need to be reexamined.

Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by jacquesm on Saturday October 31, 2015 @05:27PM (#10484275)
I disagree.

A prosecutor has the full weight of a government and the associated resources behind him. To bring those resources to bear on someone they know is innocent should be a crime all in its own right.

Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by sokoloff on Saturday October 31, 2015 @05:03PM (#10484205)
I don't see any reason why there should be symmetry between the defense's aim to get the best outcome for their client and the prosecutor's office's role to get the worst outcome.

Instead, I'm fine if every stage and every actor in the system was biased towards a finding of not guilty.

To that end, I do think it's incumbent on the prosecutors to only seek to convict those it believes are guilty rather than those it believes it can convict.

Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by fineman on Saturday October 31, 2015 @08:28PM (#10484879)
The prosecutors job is to pursue a case they know is unjust against a defendant they know is innocent?

Because this helps society?

Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by mikeash on Saturday October 31, 2015 @11:17PM (#10485284)
It shouldn't be possible for a prosecutor to know that a defendant is innocent and simultaneously be confident that they have a solid case that can result in a guilty verdict.

A prosecutor trying to optimize for conviction rates will still refrain from prosecuting people when he doesn't have a good case. It's just based on the quality of the case, not the presumed guilt or innocence of the accused.

Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by fineman on Sunday November 01, 2015 @04:11PM (#10488322)
That's an easy scenario. The prosecutor sees you (elsewhere) while the crime is being committed. Later, they charge you anyways because the evidence seems strong enough to convince others.
Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by mikeash on Sunday November 01, 2015 @05:36PM (#10488724)
Prosecutors are typically required to give the defense all evidence they possess that could possibly aid their defense. They may not actually do this, but that doesn't make it actually a prosecutor's job to prosecute in this hypothetical.
Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by fineman on Monday November 02, 2015 @12:28PM (#10493368)
Yeah, and yet the prosecutors in this story are saying they don't even have an obligation to let you know when their case has been shown to be fraudulent.

My point of eyewitness testimony is that it would truly convince the DA but wouldn't be valuable evidence in the trial. They could say "I think I saw him elsewhere" to be truthful but say it in a way that didn't give it enough weight to counteract the other, conflicting (because you weren't really there) evidence.

If this came out, the DA would not even face censure or reprimand, let alone firing or criminal charges.

Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by mikeash on Monday November 02, 2015 @07:03PM (#10496382)
If a reliable witness with no reason to lie came out and testified that they saw the suspect far away from the crime scene when the alleged crime was committed, that wouldn't be seen as compelling evidence for the innocence of the accused?
Re:How many people are in jail based on faked data? by fineman on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @01:57AM (#10498008)
I meant to specifically under-tell the story. Make sure that your testimony was questioned, don't argue strongly, etc.

I don't know the hand-ranking of various legal maneuvers but I am curious where a DA's eye-witness testimony would rank compared to a cell-phone location trace, or hair samples, etc.