News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EFF asks appeals court to “shut down the Eastern District... by whyIndeed on Saturday October 31, 2015 @12:10AM (#10481767)
I don't understand why this is an EFF fight.

From what I gather the line of reasoning is something like:

  > eff cares about technology, in particular 
    electronics and communication.

    > sometimes electronic systems, and the software these 
      systems employ, may be patented.

      > patents in general may foster innovation, but
        when misused, they may also stifle innovation.

        > technological innovation, generally speaking, is
          something the EFF cares about.

          > in texas, there exists a group of political  
            activists colluding together to willfully 
            stifle technological innovation through 
            the careful misuse of U.S. patent law.

            > although the manner in which these political 
              malefactors operate may be subtle and 
              convoluted, there is an obvious sense of the 
              goals behind their actions, and those goals 
              threaten to harm, not just a select group of 
              actors mired in interpersonal grudge matches,
              but every participant in the American civil 
              justice system, by establishing dangerous 
              precedents with long reach and odd side 
              effects that may be weaponized to create 
              widespread strife and conflict amongst anyone 
              coming up against an opponent with the time, 
              money, and the awareness of said precedents.

              > how the EFF is so certain of such intent 
                among these political actors remains 
                unclear, but because of this, the EFF is 
                willing to invest not-insignificant 
                resources in confronting and disrupting
                their malignant behaviors.

                > strategically speaking, should certain
                  specific legal decisions come to pass 
                  in an American jurisdiction, it could 
                  spell disaster for technological 
                  innovation as a whole (really?), based 
                  on the implicit logical corollaries 
                  established by carefully chosen
                  legal battles won by this group.

                  > for this reason the EFF seeks to 
                    challenge the validity of their 
                    actions and their authority to operate
                    in general.
Is that about right?
Re:EFF asks appeals court to “shut down the Eastern District... by wtallis on Saturday October 31, 2015 @12:37AM (#10481828)
It's simpler than that, and doesn't rely on any far-fetched conspiracy theories.

Nobody's actually trying or colluding to stifle innovation, they're just trying to abuse patent law to make money, with gross disregard for the purposes of patent law or the broader consequences of their actions. Perverse incentives can produce much of the same harms as a broad conspiracy, without the impracticality and implausibility of collusion.

The Eastern District of Texas and the Federal Circuit have both undergone regulatory capture, which can be incredibly damaging to the public interest even when the regulators' intentions are quite innocent.

Re:EFF asks appeals court to “shut down the Eastern District... by whyIndeed on Saturday October 31, 2015 @01:56AM (#10481953)
Okay, but I'm trying to figure out why the EFF is getting involved. It doesn't sound like their usual sort of kerfuffle.

Sure, greed, corruption, and low-brow abuse of power is repugnant in and of itself, but where does this start to become a Electronic issue?

How do the shenanigans of court district in Texas endanger an entire frontier of all things electronic?

Re:EFF asks appeals court to “shut down the Eastern District... by danparsonson on Saturday October 31, 2015 @02:28AM (#10481996)
Software patents.

See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_Frontier_Foundation - the introductory paragraph nicely sums up their remit.

Re:EFF asks appeals court to “shut down the Eastern District... by tracker1 on Saturday October 31, 2015 @02:43AM (#10482015)
Here you go, that's just one industry, and in general the problem hasn't gotten any better.

http://www.droid-life.com/2012/01/24/web-of-tech-patent-laws...

Re:EFF asks appeals court to “shut down the Eastern District... by walshemj on Saturday October 31, 2015 @08:32AM (#10482480)
Because it effects the entire industry and has negative effects for everybody.