News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by mootothemax on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @09:53AM (#1047562)
Humourless maybe, but if North Face didn't exist, the guy wouldn't be making money right now.

I don't see a problem with being satirical, but surely after making $5,000 and receiving the notice from North Face you should be prepared to stop trading?

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by philk on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:14AM (#1047613)
>> but surely after making $5,000 and receiving the notice from North Face you should be prepared to stop trading

It's somewhat puzzling to see this opinion posted on a news site that caters to entrepreneurs.

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by mootothemax on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:16AM (#1047618)
Isn't a valuable part of being an entrepreneur knowing when to quit?
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by philk on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:28AM (#1047641)
I'm not sure that "when you've just received a huge amount of free publicity" constitutes a good time to quit.
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by ErrantX on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:54AM (#1047716)
No - but it might be a clever time to change the logo, make money off the back of the publicity and side step the litigation.
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by charliepark on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @02:24PM (#1048262)
The brand is the entire point of the company. How many cheap knockoffs of North Face fleeces are there? Any competitive advantage he has is that his brand is poking fun at The North Face's brand.

If he wants to stay in business, changing his brand to something vanilla is probably the worst thing he could do.

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by ErrantX on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @02:56PM (#1048341)
Agreed. However Im sure a smart entrepeneur could come up with a logo that rides off the back of the "infamy"/publicity but doesn't leave him in court.

I cant see that the smart approach is to let them litigate... the comparative size of the companies means it is incredibly risky.

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by Goladus on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @03:20PM (#1048411)
Exactly. If I'd been him, I'd have changed the logo to be more obviously a parody (maybe made it pink or something), and changed the font or something so that it's clearly distinguishable.
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by jacquesm on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @03:23PM (#1048421)
I'd milk it for what it's worth before doing that.

The time to quit is when the cost starts to outweigh the benefits, in this case that time may not have arrived (yet).

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by mootothemax on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:31AM (#1047651)
When that free publicity carries continued lawyers fees, I'd beg to differ.
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by philk on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:42AM (#1047675)
He is a 19 year old college student; hence his downside risk is fairly limited.

On the other hand, he's received global coverage and now has the potential to make a substantial amount of cash. There's also the real possibility that negative publicity will force the North Face to back down.

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by michaelcampbell on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @11:24AM (#1047793)
Whenever someone tells you to?
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by markpercival on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:12AM (#1047610)
Why, if he can prove he's not infringing on their trademark, he should absolutely continue to make money selling his merchandise.

If IBM didn't exist you probably wouldn't have Microsoft - doesn't mean they shouldn't compete with each other.

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by mootothemax on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:19AM (#1047622)
If he can prove he's not infringing on their trademark, it'll be a sad day for every entrepreneur out there.

Actually, no, I'm wrong, scratch that. What I meant to say was: it'll be a sad day for every entrepreneur without Chinese contacts.

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by mrkurt on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @11:05AM (#1047748)
Really? The test is whether he's diluting the value of North Face's trademark. I think a court could reasonably decide he's not. There's a long and golden history of people creating satirical products that are meant to poke fun at trademarks.
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by raganwald on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @12:54PM (#1048060)
One of the tests is whether he's diluting North Face's trademark. The other is whether he's damaging it. Freedom to satirize is not the same thing as freedom to create a satirical product.

There is a long history of such products, but that does not guarantee a defense.

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by mrkurt on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @02:17PM (#1048246)
Trademark tarnishment is a kind of dilution (the other being blurring). In this case, I think it will be hard to argue tarnishment and easier to argue blurring.

The real point I was trying to make, though, is that a court might find in his favor, and it wouldn't really be "a sad day for every entrepreneur without Chinese contacts". It would be a reasonable decision. Finding against them might also be a reasonable decision, though I'm prone to want to protect satire as much as possible. :)

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by Goladus on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @03:24PM (#1048424)
Yeah I think if this logo had appeared in a Simpsons Episode or on Penny-Arcade it would clearly not be infringement. The fact that he's selling clothes changes things.
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by rosser on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @07:20PM (#1048990)
Exactly. Parodic or otherwise, he's using his riff on TNF's trademarks for commercial purposes. That seems to be the most important detail, in terms of how suits and rulings have trended, in my (admittedly brief) digging into the topic.
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by cabalamat on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:21PM (#1049338)
> surely after making $5,000 and receiving the notice from North Face you should be prepared to stop trading?

Why? If people are continuing to buy their stuff, they are obviously making things people want.