Re:The West Is Choked by Fear
by rbanffy on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @09:27AM
(#1047494)
Stop modding theotherside down. This discussion is important.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Sorry, but no. Freedom of speech is a really important thing and someone who says "Fuck freedom of speech" is not someone I can reasonably agree with.
Also, the fact that he's created a new account just to post this discredits his arguments further. "I disagree with this article but not enough to lose a couple of points of karma".
Re:The West Is Choked by Fear
by theotherside on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @10:32AM
(#1047654)
I actually meant "fuck this being about freedom of speech".
I made a new account because I run a business, and don't want that associated with my own personal beliefs.
Re:The West Is Choked by Fear
by mtinkerhess on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @09:59AM
(#1047580)
Agreed. Comments should be voted according to how much they add to the discussion, not by whether you agree with the author's opinion.
I don't agree ... votes should be given for any reason a reader wants. Sometimes the actual post is so stupid and off-topic that it doesn't deserve a response ... and the rating system is there in the first place to distinguish between the good posts and the bad ones.
Granted ... this particular comment was pretty much on topic, and contains a very popular point-of-view in many circles ... so personally I haven't down-voted "theotherside", preferring to give him a reply instead.