News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Random Acts of Optimization by jerf on Thursday October 29, 2015 @04:45PM (#10474148)
And in theory, dependent types are the awesomest thing ever. But they're not ready yet, and there's no guarantee they ever will be. There's a gulf between even having a few focused, carefully-chosen proofs of concept and a practically-useful technology.

(For that matter, I just grabbed that example off the top of my head as the thing I knew that most resembled the various fancy optimizers I've seen over the years, but it seems to me that dependent typing are full of things that would be darned useful for an optimizer. It would be funny if the fastest path towards whole-program optimization went through dependent types being practical.)

Re:Random Acts of Optimization by johncolanduoni on Thursday October 29, 2015 @06:06PM (#10474715)
> And in theory, dependent types are the awesomest thing ever. But they're not ready yet, and there's no guarantee they ever will be.

I think the reason dependent types haven't made it into practical programming has less to do with them being not ready and more to do with them being fundamentally challenging to learn. I have a pretty strong pure math background and it still took me a significant amount of time to wrap my head around them to the point that I could write non-trivial proofs using them, let alone programs. For programmers who have never done much formal logic or who have never heard of a category, I can't imagine how much time it would take to get the prerequisite knowledge.

Another issue is the fundamental problem of creating a new language; you have to build up a ton of extra machinery (libraries, tooling, etc.) to even think about it becoming more than a toy, even if you don't care about it being mainstream. Rust has the backing of a large open-source company and a ton of really smart people dedicated to bringing it to primetime, but it is still going to take a long time for it to get there. Dependently typed languages like F* and Idris don't have the same manpower behind them and also have to face fundamental challenges like integrating formally verified code with a world full of unverified (but useful) code.

Re:Random Acts of Optimization by saosebastiao on Thursday October 29, 2015 @04:54PM (#10474201)
I think dependent types are amazing, but even the tiny subset of dependent types known as refinement types opens up huge avenues for optimization. Some optimizations (loop nest optimizations for a simple example) might only be feasible with static range definitions or with profile guided optimization...but if you throw in refinement types, you now have static guarantees as to the cardinality or range of a variable, and loop nest optimizations can be statically determined. I think full dependent typing could be great, but compilers can still be improved with small language improvements.
Re:Random Acts of Optimization by tel on Thursday October 29, 2015 @05:18PM (#10474379)
They're ready in small forms in Haskell today. The compiler doesn't take a whole lot of advantage of these yet, but you start to see avenues toward it.