News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Being a Bastard (Cultivating online communities) by jrockway on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @02:19AM (#1047050)
I have seen mst in action, and his techniques are pretty effective. I think I have had just as much luck with newbies by being nice, however... but perhaps not.

(My reaction upon being yelled at would be to leave, but this is not the behavior I observe in other people. mst has quite a few fans that started off as "victims" of the techniques he describes in the artice.)

Re:On Being a Bastard (Cultivating online communities) by houseabsolute on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @02:31AM (#1047060)
I'm glad that this technique worked for a few people that are now friends with mst, but I think an even better outcome might have been achieved with a gentler approach. Naturally, how mst goes about his business is his own affair, but I think it's worth having the opposing viewpoint especially in an article like this.
Re:On Being a Bastard (Cultivating online communities) by jrockway on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @02:41AM (#1047076)
The thing is, the people he yells at tend to stick around. There is not some tiny in-group of mst fans.

To be fair, though, you can only have so many msts in a community. When the other people are nice, a dialog like:

  newbie: I'm dumb and can't read, do my work for me
  mst: PASTE YOUR CODE IDIOT!!
  nicer_person: newbie: good idea... although to be fair, there isn't much to read on this subject
often emerges. Now newbie has a friend in nicer_person; someone who probably wouldn't have said anything if mst hadn't yelled at the newbie.