Re:VMware GPL Enforcement Suit in Germany Continues
by amscanne on Saturday October 31, 2015 @12:33AM
(#10481821)
While I'm sure that's an opinion held by some, it seems unreasonable when you have both EXPORT_SYMBOL and EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL. If there is no distinction, then why does one exist? I think there's a good argument to be made regarding the intent of the application of the license across the API.
The test used by the industry for derivative works usually requires a full implementation of the same code with another OS than Linux (e.g the nvidia drivers which shares 95% of the codebase between Linux and Windows). Some ported-over-from-an-RTOS drivers fall into this as well, but there's rarely enough value in them that they shouldn't be opensourced.
In the end there are so many nice features hidden behind EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL that it's rarely worth it to go the proprietary route.