What you have in car dealerships is a classic example of regulatory capture [0], where most people don't buy a car that often, so they're not particularly focused on dealer laws. But dealers have all the incentive in the world to lobby for restrictive rules. And, since dealers are by their nature distributed, and often have the proceeds to be "good community citizens" (e.g., sponsor a little league team), their views have even more weight.
What about the jobs? Is the argument that they don't serve any legitimate purpose, such that they'd go away if they're not forced to be kept around through legislation? Jobs aren't a good reason to favor stagnation over dynamism in an economy. Improvements in productivity have led to drastically more jobs over time, rather than less, the same would be true in this case. Plus, the existing dealers would continue to have a leg up on sales and distribution, it would take a long time to build out any competing systems.
The customer is the one that should be able to choose between a cheaper price with a lower service, or a higher price with more service. The problem here is that companies want to provide the cheap alternative but aren't allowed to do so.
If a dealer cannot compete with a direct sale company on price and service, doesn't that make their business model flawed/outdated.
If a society flips and completely changes the economic/legislative landscape under which companies operate, it creates a very unstable business environment and discourages capex especially.
This would not be good for the long term economic health.
Whoa. Nobody is "taking over" the dealerships. What is being discussed is changing the laws that protect their monopoly.
Modifying the law to allow Dis-integrated deliver of sales and service is not going to mean a massive loss of jobs. Dealerships still have huge services businesses that will continue to thrive.
Dealer direct, sounds good. Until you find out that car you really want has a demonstration center that is too far away, in a place you don't want to go. Until you find out repairs are done at an authorized shop that handles so many brands they cannot get it right. Until you have serious problems with your car and that manufacturer is so far away they can ignore you for a good amount of time... and so on.
While not everyone has a good experience at a dealer I have never had a bad one and considering the number of vehicles I have gone through, well. Dealers aren't there just to sell cars. They they maintain them, they work to keep you happy so you come back. This means they act as go between consumer and manufacturer and can often push the manufacturer to fix things they might just overlook.
Tesla is fine as it is now simply because they don't sell enough cars to matter, let alone to the majority of people their cars are not affordable and the customers who do buy have the time to go anywhere they need to to buy a car or even have someone go get it. When, and it is a very big when, Tesla has any real volume let us watch how they handle problems