News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Do we need Engineering Managers? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @06:32PM (#10461661)
Sounds like you've seen engineering management done badly, and you don't like it. But if you saw a self-managed team done badly, you wouldn't like that, either.

Good engineering management insulates you from the corporate politics and irrelevant stuff going on above you. You really want that insulation, because those who don't do corporate politics can still have politics done to them.

Re:Ask HN: Do we need Engineering Managers? by montbonnot on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @06:39PM (#10461697)
I've seen very good managers but the ratio is bad. %10 vs %90 of bad ones. A world with less management could be a world with less politics. I understand that a conflict between teams, for example, is a problem that can only be resolved at the management level. The question is, what if these 2 teams become one? The rest is about company re-org, new manager assignment, etc. Politics... as you said.
Re:Ask HN: Do we need Engineering Managers? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:06PM (#10461820)
> A world with less management could be a world with less politics.

Wow, are you an optimist. Sure, it could be, but it probably won't be.

You seem to think that engineers are wonderful human beings and managers are horrible. It's not that simple. If you're finding 10% good managers and 90% bad ones, you'd likely find 10% engineers good at interacting with others while self-managing, and 90% who will get into petty vindictive garbage and make your office a miserable place.

Re:Ask HN: Do we need Engineering Managers? by montbonnot on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:06PM (#10462089)
I agree with that. Engineering managers are ex-engineers after all so the ratio 10/90 applies at any level.

What if you promote a "bad" engineer? She/he would have a much bigger impact on people = more impact on the company. The problem is not about engineers vs managers. The problem is about micro bubbles within a company which create micro cultures that are often driven by these (micro) managers. A solution would be to put everyone at the same level. That sounds very naive and provocative... but after all, there hasn't been much innovation in that space within the last 20-30 years. We manage engineers like we used to manage workers in a factory. I think the model does not apply anymore. That's just my naive/ideal world opinion...